Gucci PH I and Dirty English a bit similar?

[Zgb]

When I sprayed Dirty English it instantly reminded me of Gucci PH I. Did that happen to you to?

Wich one is better in your opinion?

I'm thinking of adding Gucci PH I to my collectio, from one reason it has the retro feel, from other I already own Gucci PH II.

[HDS1963]

I can't respond to this poll because I like both equally but for different reasons. Which is maybe why I have both of them. Gucci pH 1 is a much dryer fragrances than Dirty English which has a boozier, fruitier feel to it. Dirty English is closer to the original Tommy Bahama in my opinion.

[Zgb]

So, in your opinion I might want both in my collection? I'll have to test them both simultaneously to reach a better conclusion, I guess.

[HDS1963]

Well, I have Tommy Bahama, Gucci Homme I and Dirty English and wear them all, so maybe that's your answer lol...

[petruccijc]

I find them to be different.

IMO Gucci PH I is worth owning - not so for Dirty English.

[Zgb]

Never tried Tommy Bahama so I can't tell. Obviously we have a case of different fragrances wich share a vibe like Azzaro PH, Paco Rabanne PH, YSL Kouros.