Thanks for the review, eau_de_amor. Did you have a favorite of the four? When I checked out the ponies, the salesman described #2 as "the chocolate one" and said that it was selling the most.
Today I'm wearing the next Sisley, Eau de Sisley 2.
It went on mostly citrus, but with a bright burst of mint. Given time, a sort of brown Lipton tea smell came in, which formed most of the heart of Eau de Sisley 2. If forced, I could pick out vetiver and maybe petitgrain, as well as something flowery, but everything really came together into a tea smell for me. That's about it, really. It started more sweet and citrusy, but with that bright mint, and ended up a bit more woody, but only in the sense that the tea smell could be described as vaguely woody, not in the sense that this actually ever smelled like wood.
I get the feeling that this could really sing in very hot weather. There's a brightness in Eau de Sisley 2 that permeates from top to bottom. It's been warm today, but not scorching, and I'm sad to say that I've found this a bit forgettable, but I really do think that it could be amazing on a truly hot summer day.