Bergdorf's in New York has it. To me it is a lot like Wild Fern or English Fern, but I will sample it a few more times before I make up my mind. It did not, however, bring out a "wow" in me. The bottle is really beautiful, however.
Last edited by Joe_Frances; 4th December 2010 at 04:59 AM. Reason: Additional Information
Took 3 test wearings for me to understand or 'get' this one.
Honestly, it came off as a little femme @ first for me but I was fairly determined to see if it could work to help break me out of a scent genre rut.
The lady of the house isn't all that impressed. She wants her guy to smell macho and while I like to accommodate the preference - it gets old. She just may have to suck it up on this one & give in to some 'nose' training 'cause I think I should have this one.
Last edited by SoGent; 13th December 2010 at 11:28 AM.
I can't believe I was at Bergdorf in NY and I totally forgot to smell this when I was there. (sigh)
I love this scent! I always have one herbal fresh scent. For the last 2 years it's been L'eau de Neroli, Diptyque. Prior I stocked up on Basilico, Aqua di Parma for 5-6 years. Fougere Royal will be the most elegant so far. I thought the sillage was perfect. It cut through my friend's perfume and restaurant scents. If my boyfriend wore this, I would think he had great taste!
Last edited by Kalynne; 13th December 2010 at 04:05 AM.
This one is excellent, but sadly, the staying power/projection on this one is kind of weak for me.
I am going to shamble back over to Bergdorf's and steal a few more squirts of FR, and see if I was right or wrong before. Since the opinion of a Basenoter of your inestimable reputation must be given due regard. ;0)
Finally getting around to doing a side by side test of the 'vintage' and 'new release' and have to completely agree with mrclmind's assessment. This is one of those cases where the updated version is as good or better than the original.
Granted, my vintage decant is an edc but I believe it's still a fair comparison. The top notes of the vintage are very, very smooth and does radiate fern moreso than the new - which would be obvious when comparing the notes.
The progression of the new is definitely spicier than the original but not at all sharp. The oakmoss & coumarin are almost identical in intensity & depth with tonka showing up for sure in the recreation. This new kid truly is awesome & quite a bit different for me. Glad I found the Amouage Harrods Ltd Editions and this one & have targeted its first true use as New Years Eve. Think I'll layer the old with the new.
Last edited by SoGent; 15th December 2010 at 02:57 AM.
I finally got to try it and buy it. Great scent! But I seem to have a problem. I bought it in Vegas and didn't open it up until I got home. The nameplate is off it and the back corners seem to be chipped. Did anyone else have a problem with the bottle?
Scents I have that are not in the database.
Amouage Molook Attar
Full Incense - Montale
Oudh Lacquer by Soivohle
Shalimar Ode de la Vanille by Guerlain
Mukhalat Makaki Perfume Oil by Swiss Arabian
Man Amber by Halston
Absolue pour le Soir by Maison Francis Kurkdjian
Puro Intense by Nejma
"...her fragrance all in my keeping; softly she comes in the night." Lyrics, Gordon Lightfoot, "Softly."
I am now sitting in a cloud of Fougere Royale and my SOTD which is Lady Vengeance (hahahaha). I have sprayed FR on my left arm. My friend brought to our office his newly purchased bottle of Fougere Royale which looks so nice and heavy. It is a great scent. Lots of lemon on top. At the heart I can smell a lot of greens. It is indeed a fresh-spicy-green scent with high quality ingredients. For lovers of Duc de Vervins, Carthusia Uomo, you will definitely love this one.
Last edited by volley2; 15th June 2011 at 06:29 AM.
I tested this at NM today. I get Balenciaga Pour Homme out of it. White bottle with light blue accents? Real nice.
The new Fougere Royale has nothing to do with the original, but it's actually a smaller, lighter, greener, less spicy relative of Havana (Aramis). It's well-blended and the ingredients smell like some money was put into it, but it's even duller than the Aramis. Don't get me wrong, I used to love Havana, but its reliance on affable spices led me to lose interest in it pretty fast. With the new so-called Fougere Royale, it happened a lot faster.
But you can't expect much from a perfumer (Rodrigo Flores-Roux) who thinks Acqua di Gio is one of the best fragrances ever made. I'll take one Havana to ten Fougere Royale reissues any day.
Last edited by pluran; 13th June 2011 at 09:48 AM.
Since this thread has been resurrected, I purchased a small decant. I think the new FR EdP is a good "modernized" version of the original Fougere Royale though I've never smelled the original. I would speculate that it was more in the fashion of English Fern or Crown Fougere as a true fougere based around the distinct lavender-geranium-tonka accord. FR has this structure but it is heavily embellished with aromatic elements thus making it a aromatic fougere in the fashion of YSL's excellent albeit affordable Jazz. My favorite part of the FR is the delicate floral heart of carnation, rose, geranium, heliotrope, and jasmine--but this stage is brief and quickly gives way to the dry tonka/cedar base. Additionally, the original Fougere Royale was probably of EdC concentration and may have contained potentially sickening (or lethal) doses of natural coumarin.
I tested this a couple days ago, when Basenotes was down, and didn't get to post my impressions...but I loved it. I will wear it again soon and post my comments then.
It felt very luxurious and serious, if that makes sense. A 'man's man' sort of fragrance. I usually shy away from these sort of scents (Havana, Azzaro Pour Homme) but this one has just a little something extra that I like. If I had to compare it to any scent at all, it would be Rive Gauche Pour Homme, of course with the anise removed.
"When you become comfortable with uncertainty. infinite possibilities open up in your life"
-- Eckhart Tolle
Resurrecting the thread, as I happened across TS's blog.
I would just like to say that the current keepers of the Houbigant brand should die of shame for calling that new thing they’re selling Fougère Royale. Is this a prank?
Anybody wants to comment? I haven't smelled either (old or new).
I don't know the old one but the reissue is a very good fragrance, it's worth owning.
The old samples are all more aromatic than the new version, which is less identifiable as a classic fougere and to this nose, a bit more like a sweet fougere/oriental. I know, sounds unlikely but the the citrus and what I believe is vanilla make it sweeter than the old versions. Definitely not a classic or aromatic fougere.
As for the name: Though I can smell a connection between the old and the new release, I am perplexed by the the decision at Houbigant to fall back on the old name. Sure, we crazy afficianados will gladly buy something called "Fougere Royale" but as a wider mass market fragrance, I don't believe it will ever fly. From a true niche house, I would understand the marketing strategy, but Houbigant, though no longer an independent company, is definitely not niche.
I suspect this fragrance is not selling well and may disappear over time. (I have four bottles just in case).
Thanks - so your take is that it is good, though different from older versions.
TS doesn't explain her statement any further, and unfortunately, she also says that FR will not be included in the upcoming book.
(They will include 3 other perfumes, reconstructed at the Osmotheque)
Last edited by Griff; 19th June 2011 at 05:07 PM.
Oof! This scent is awesome.
"The force that through the green fuse drives the flower // drives my green age..." Dylan Thomas
Keep the new version 20 years in your dress room, and it will be the same fantastic vintage Fougere
I agree with our statement partially - it's very good scent, they should name it Fougere Royal 2 or whatever, but not the original name.
Anyway, worth it's price tag IMO
This is a very nice scent. Smooth as silk and great for the office, even on another cold day. When I first put it on, I thought "this smells like Spring". Very mature yet approachable scent. I don't own anything like it.
This is a very nice office scent! I wore it today for a day of meetings and a Board Meeting tonight. Surprising duration for just 3 sprays. I had a comment this morning that "somebody took a shower" from my acerbic but kind-hearted HR Director!
You make it sound pretty good Chuck, the only thing holding me back is the carnation note that is listed. Is the carnation noticeable?