I have only tried Havana Vanille and Tauer Lddm - to be honest, I liked both but thought they were a tad overrated. I would say my disappointment ranged from minor (Tauer) to modest (HV), enough where they wouldn't make the cut for me personally to shell that kind of $ out for them. If I WAS to (or somebody gave me the choice of one free) I would definitely choose the Lddm. I see it as more wearable and certainly more masculine. I find vanilla for me to be a very infrequent type scent to wear. My vote is the Tauer Lddm.