Why, dont give up that easily I would say.
Those you mentioned I can understand not liking, except CW I dont approve of any, either.
MAybe you should just try a wider variety. The classics, different lines (say : styles) such as PdE, Tauer etc. They all offer distinguishingly different characteristics which may lead you to your kind of style.
Only because you are hard to please doesnt mean its impossible that there's "the" perfect scent for you.
The other option would be that frags are just not catching you interest all that much, after all and that's no worries, I'd say, it's certainly the cheaper way out.