I'm not really sure that any of those would be great for a high schooler. JV is definitely a formal scent, but it's really more mature than high school. It's not really something that high school girls would go for, plus longevity isn't great. Le Male really isn't a formal scent either, more of a party one. I don't really know much about those everyday ones. Give CK Euphoria a try, it'd be a good one for everyday fall wear, Burberry London is also an awesome fall scent as well, but some have had problems with longevity.