Terre d'Hermes or Guerlain L'Instant - EDT or EDP?

[Kbar]

Whats up.

I decided i want a new winter fragrance and after previously trying both and liking them as well i decided it is time to buy one.

The only thing i didnt get a chance to try is the EDP version of TDH, but i am sure it is great.

If you were to choose only one at this time, which would you choose and what version; EDT or EDP?

Thanks for the help

[Scentational]

I only tested the EDT version of both yet, but without hesitation L'Instant.
1) I prefer the smell, of course
2) TdH is often described as better for hotter weather, when L'Instant is a very appropriate choice for cold weather.

[JonB]

Easy, either version of TdH. Can't beat that flinty orange magic.

[ctran019]

Terre d'hermes either version. EDT of guerlain doesnt last long enough to enjoy and the EDP version is super cloying and hard to find.

[CanwllCorfe]

I choose L'instant EDP! Deep, rich, and comforting. I love it!

[Str8_SHAVER]

Terre D'Hermes (Perfume).......

[StylinLA]

Both very nice. Buy both.

If you have to go with one for now- I say L'Instant de Guerlain Pour Homme.

TdH very well crafted scent too, but L'Instant is incredible to me.

[CanwllCorfe]

Yeah I don't really get the love for Terre d'Hermes. Definitely not bad, but I just find it boring. Well made? Yes. Just not really interesting.

[Kbar]

I think i am going to get L'Instant. I saw the edp on amazon but i cant find it anymore =\

[CanwllCorfe]

Yeah the only place I see it at is Escentual.

http://www.escentual.com/guerlain/li...nstanthomme10/

I know someone had mentioned that they knew a place who sold it for relatively cheap overseas. I know it's easier to get in Europe. It's even at the French Sephora.

[checker]

L'instant by a mile, folks the EDP version is on beautyencounter!

[Delicious Scent]

I can only find EDT version of L'instant, is that still good? Or Terre?

[drseid]

I own them all and like them all. That said, TDH is my favorite scent, so obviously I would choose that one easily. Both the edt and pp are equally good IMO, but for winter I think I would go pp.

[hednic]

Terre d'Hermes Parfum

[G.303]

Terre D'Hermes either version!!!
Gary

[vox]

for TDH? not my cup of tea.
for L'Instant? go with the EDP version.

[Jack Hunter]

Terre d' Hermes - I cannot live with the rubber vinly note, I have tried and its not for me.

G' L ' Instant Extreme - Fantastic fragrance, awesome. A perfect Ten!

[sr_dedo]

I'm new in basenotes, this is my first post.
Terre and L'instant are differents.
L'instant edp is very gourdmand. I prefere terre edt and l'instant edp, but are different

[Oslo-Fjord]

Terre D'Hermes (Perfume).......

+1.

[kasae]

sr_dedo, welcome to basenotes.

I've only tried Terre d'Hermes once in EdT and L'Insant pour Homme a few times, but I say the L'Instant. Terre came across a bit too much as cologne as opposed to a unique scent.

[sr_dedo]

thanks kasae!
if you can, buy terre (edt or edp, there are not big differences) and l'instant EDP!!

[Bonoanimoes]

Terre EDP , Off Course