Geranium Pour Monsieur

[Rumblefish]

Testing this one now...it seems like--quite literally--the perfect suit sent. That said, I'm fortunate not to have to wear suits tremendously often at this stage in my life. Even so, this is one for the wishlist, and one that seems 100% worth its price to me. May have to factor this into my 5 year plan

Any fans of this particular frag on the boards?

[MrFragranceReview]

Toothpaste Pour Monsieur is what it should have been called!

[Force of One]

I totally agree it smells like toothpaste! Just sampled this the other day. Really didn't like it at all.

[Oslo-Fjord]

I totally agree it smells like toothpaste! Just sampled this the other day. Really didn't like it at all.

Agreed.

[Roc_Xel]

The only Malle I really don't like . To me it does not smell exactly like toothpaste but it does smell exactly the same as when I go to the dentist, some kind of tooth desinfectant or something, or the rinse product. I wanted to love it so badly, especially given my overall Malle attraction, but I simply can't. Don t want a remember my dentist every time I wear this one. A big No for me.

[ziffy321]

I'm one that really likes this and always get a compliment when I've worn it. Wore it to my company dinner last month and had 2 people actually wrote down the name. Doesn't remind me of toothpaste at all. Floral with mint overtones in a very masculine way. And at a dinner wearing a suit where there's dancing going on later in the evening, heavy scents I've worn in the past turned out to be disastrous (Bois du Portugal, Musc Ravageur). This one works perfectly when dancing and sweating wearing a suit.

One of my favorite "all year round" scents.

[cosmopolit]

I don't think mint is the problem--in fact, I think the mint note is handled very well.

I would certainly consider this as a warm-weather fragrance if it wasn't for the fact that I pick up an offputting citronella note--so I won't be considering this unless I head for mosquito-infested climes.

[hirch_duckfinder]

The accord seems wrong to me being that powerful. It would work if it was as diffusive as, say, derby but that minty geranium needs to be subtle for me and GpM shouts VERY LOUD.

[Trebor]

The accord seems wrong to me being that powerful. It would work if it was as diffusive as, say, derby but that minty geranium needs to be subtle for me and GpM shouts VERY LOUD.

The problem with Geranium Pour Monsieur is that, after about 30 minutes, it's too BLOODY QUIET!

[HDS1963]

My problem with GpM is that it's a one trick pony, seems very linear and when it's doing what it's doing it's not really terribly pleasant. It's ok, just not great.

[MrFragranceReview]

It is very linear, not worth the price for mr although, I can see why some like it, it's VERY different and unique.

[petruccijc]

I wear a suit. I would never wear this fragrance with a suit - or pretty much at any other time either.

[mr. reasonable]

I enjoy Geranium Pour Monsieur as an alternative to other more 'standard' summer scents - altho HK is not in the tropics our Spring / Summer is easily compatible to Singapore etc - sometimes even more oppressive. The way the mint is handled actually reminds me more of freshly grown mint I used to use in tea, it's quite soft and uplifting, so no problem there for me - it's a nice change from citrus or lavender styled scents and very natural. It seems to last pretty well for me during the day and I agree that it's quite crisp and dressy - fine for work.

Just an after thought - I wore the Creed Selection Verte a few times and liked that but it is very fleeting, of course. GpM is the only mint I have come across that has the same natural feel to me, and extending the mint with the geranium solves the short lived nature of SV in it's own kind of way.

[blondex199667]

I love the Malle collection as well as geranium but I have to add my name to the list of those who feel this smells just like toothpaste.

[Master-Classter]

an alternative might be C&S's Oxford and Cambridge. It's a minty lavender.

Personally I liked GrM though. not enough to buy a bottle, but it was a very interesting experience.


PS:
http://www.basenotes.net/threads/253...-Pour-Monsieur
http://www.basenotes.net/threads/233...rther-Thoughts
http://www.basenotes.net/threads/225...-pour-Monsieur

[MrFragranceReview]

Its unique and I wanted to like it for that fact alone but, it does smell just like toothpaste and I can't shake that fact.

[scentaddiction]

My problem with GpM is that it's a one trick pony, seems very linear and when it's doing what it's doing it's not really terribly pleasant. It's ok, just not great.

Well said. Good, not great, and at that price, I would take Heeley's mint.

[Roc_Xel]

an alternative might be C&S's Oxford and Cambridge. It's a minty lavender.

Personally I liked GrM though. not enough to buy a bottle, but it was a very interesting experience.


PS:
http://www.basenotes.net/threads/253...-Pour-Monsieur
http://www.basenotes.net/threads/233...rther-Thoughts
http://www.basenotes.net/threads/225...-pour-Monsieur

For me tbh these two have pretty much nothing in common except maybe for a few notes they might share.

I love Oxf. and Camb but can't wear GpM. I don't get much of the peppermint in the C&S by the way, nothing compared to the Malle's. I smell way more the lavender obviously, and the Oak Moss and Sandalwood. Bergamotte is also detectable, but the mint is really tamed.

[Larimar]

The problem with Geranium Pour Monsieur is that, after about 30 minutes, it's too BLOODY QUIET!

Exactly!

[hirch_duckfinder]

The problem with Geranium Pour Monsieur is that, after about 30 minutes, it's too BLOODY QUIET!

I do like some loud frags as well as many quiet ones but this strikes me as the type of frag that would work as a quiet cologne type. For a loud frag [i.e. Trebor stylee ;-)] it may go quiet, but for a quiet one - its BLOODY LOUD...

[Killer_Vavoom]

Yes, definitely smelling like toothpaste. Geranium extract is very cheap in price and I just don't understand the inflated price of this toothpaste fragrance. Ungaro III flings it out of the water with its tail any moment of the day.