Whaddya know. On Thanksgiving day, I stop by the Post Office to mail back my netflix movie and lo & behold, in my box is samples from my friend Oaksbluff that weren't there yesterday when I stopped by to pick up mail.
Dan was kind enough to send me both renditions and after sampling the current formula, I am in awe of how much it is similar to Gucci Pour Homme original (1976). Trust me when I say I am not disappointed. On the contrary, it's as terrific as I expected and leaves no doubt about getting a Bee Bottle as soon as the Holidays are past.
What I'd like to know is who else smells the distinct similarities in these two leather chypres?
ointments and perfume delight the heart....
I have only smelled the current formula and it's gorgeous! Very luxurious! One in the wishlist.
I still like the similarities of both and after doing 2 side by side wearings today, Derby is superior. The disparity isn't much, but it's enough to warrant owning Derby alongside the Gucci. My wife chose Derby both times in blind sniffs.
Im pleased you like this one Aromi
Do you get the flash of peppermint in the topnotes of Derby that is not present in the Gucci?
A few minutes ago, I sampled the vintage Derby for the first time and it is definitely related to the heavier chypres made back in the day. Both are different and both are so damn good that it's going to be difficult to choose one.
My wife likes the lighter, current formula better than the vintage whereas the denser florals in the vintage are right up my alley. I have a dilemma.
To be honest, in the absence of a side-by-side, i do not really detect the difference between the new version and the original (which, ironically, used to be commonly available when it first came out). The new one retains the main "Derby" character based on my memory, which is enough for me.
Grab all versions available to you now. You can then wear whichever Derby you are in the mood for at any time ;o)
ointments and perfume delight the heart....
I must concede that I had not acknowledged the connection between Gucci Pour Homme and Derby,but testing them side by side,they are clearly close cousins. Gucci feels more herbal, greener and with a a slightly sharper version of leather. Derby is smoother, slightly more floral in the middle, and probably the slightly better balanced. In a previous thread someone mentioned a similarity between Equipage and Derby, but I see the Hermes being closer to Gucci Pour Homme.
Last edited by Bartlebooth; 27th November 2010 at 06:23 PM.
I never really thought of comparing GPH and Derby, because I don't really smell the chypre effect in the Gucci...whereas it's immediately evident in the Guerlain. Plus the Gucci has just SO much cedar to my nose.
Interesting you bring this up, Mike. I just pulled my decant of GPH from Aromi actually (thanks D!) based on this thread In terms of superiority I must confess that Derby has it, hands down... just my opinion.. but I know I'm not the only one who'll be rushing out after the holidays to get a bee of Derby. Our BN friend xmen has the GPH for sale and I believe MJF does as well but I'm not 100% sure on that.
I have this haunting fantasy of finding a bottle of Derby from the '80s, at its original, affordable price, just sitting on the shelf in some old pharmacy. Or maybe at a garage sale at some bargain price, even though I never go to garage sales.
My question to the basenoters: has this actually happened to anyone on BN? Or am I doomed to buying decants, or a costly new bee bottle, if I want to own some? I'm afraid only a bottle would do, since by all accounts it's a must-have.
I am still dreaming on getting a bottle of Derby. Don't know yet when that dream will turn to reality. =( Hopefully next year.
So there is still hope mrcologneguy! Hang in there!
I agree that Gucci PH is just Cedar overload whereas Derby is much more sophisticated
at best Gucci is the teenage edition of Guerlains Derby
Off-Site Decants =) (updated 05/16/12)
Be careful: I have smelled vintage Derby that has turned bad. Make sure you're buying from a reputable seller.
The carnation and moss accord in Derby drive me insane.
Very good indeed! It sells for around $3/ml now in the 100ml sizes.. even more per ml for the 50ml. BUT.. that's not actually terrible for vintage, and Derby is potent stuff. By holding off on buying decants, especially from the L'Art et la Matiere series, the money could add up quickly.
... and now the beautiful Sous le Vent is also on my radar thanks to a wonderful gentleman here on BN who just happens to also be a terrible, terrible enabler!
I just tried re-issued Derby from a TPC sample before going to bed. The drydown is very similar to Mitsouko to me.