Who wants to bankroll complete fragrance foolishness? Not me! From what I've read here and being fond of the vetiver genre, I have reason to believe I might like Malle's Vetiver Extraordinaire. I'll be near a Barney's tomorrow and will drop in, squirt some VE on and mill around a bit before making a yay or nay determination. I've made enough mistakes already. 1/27/11 follow up: So glad I tried the Malle VE first! Unpleasantly shrill opening and short legs. No go. Also tried the Mark Birley Charles Street. If you'd like to smell like a pipe tobacco humidor, this scent is for you! I pass.