Welcome to Basenotes. I'm sorry to hear about your negative experience but just know that you're not the only person this has happened to. It's important that you're reporting it here though.
I'm a little surprised that you continued to do business with them after the problem with the first batch and with no resolution. IMHO, the titles you're mentioning are probably not fake (just not that popular and worthwhile for fakers--except Light Blue) but perhaps contain damaged juice due to improper storage issues. Other businesses have been reported on BN with similar problems (non-responsiveness, etc). If you can find out who is running the company/web site, you might want to report them to the Better Business Bureau and any other relevant agency.
I recommend you do a bit of research here and find better e-tailers for your purchases. There are some reliable and trustworthy ones available. Meanwhile, enjoy your visits here. It's a great place for us "fragrance junkies!"