Maybe Epice Marine or L'humaniste?
I'm looking for my perfect fit aquatic / beachy / sea / coast fragrance and I have very particular criteria:
1. Light, happy, bright and pleasant scent. To give an example, I love Dior Homme Cologne 2013. That is my go-to citrus. I'm looking for sort of the same qualities (not necessarily same ingredients) in an aquatic.
2. Smells like a postcard impression of the sea, NOT a literal sea smell. I'm talking about the feeling of sun, blue sky, sweet and salty sea air and a gentle breeze blowing through a sunny coast.
3. Stays fresh, light and aquatic for the entire life of the fragrance. No strange turns. No drying down to something warm, overly woody or spicy, etc.
4. Preferably a high quality scent with high quality materials. I know aquatics must make use of some cheap synthetics by nature, but as we know many of these scents occupy a wasteland of failed flankers and cheap copycats with a budget that runs out of cash by the end of the top notes. No $10 Adidas sport flankers, etc. Not TOO expensive. No Creeds or Amouages, please. Sort of in the mid to top end designer or more standard niche price range.
What I've already considered
Nautica Voyage - Own it and like it, but can come off a little cheap and chemical.
South Water - Awaiting a sample I ordered!
Acqua di Gio - This is currently my front runner that ticks the most boxes. Although it doesn't smell dated, it does have a slight 90s vibe to it, but I can probably overlook it.
Sel Marin - Definitely a literal sea smell I found highly unpleasant.
Aqva Marine - Good, but the seaweed note reminds me of sushi wrap.
Bergamotto Marino - Good opening, then turns into a pure jasmine bomb on me.
L'eau d'Issey - Good, but to me is a straight woody citrus. I don't get sea or beach out of it.
Polo Blue - More of a clean shower scent?
Set Sail St. Barts - Haven't tried, but sounds more like an exotic drink than an exotic coast. Not sure about smelling like booze?
Aqva and Gio Essenza - Both turn too dark and intense for what I'm going for.
Chanel Bleu - Own it and love it, but has a warm and rich dry down.
Beyond Paradise Men - A bit too fruity, floral and abstract.
Eau de Merveilles - Quite minerally and reminds me of a beach in winter. I'm going for summer!
Guerlain Homme L'eau - Nice mojito vibe, but not an aquatic.
Voyage d'Hermes - Nice, but not my bag. Dislike mentholy mint.
Hermes Jardin line - Didn't work for me at all.
So? Have I tapped everything out and should I go with good old Acqua di Gio? Or are there any gems out there I've left undiscovered?
Thanks for your help!
Last edited by TrimmTrabb; 11th June 2014 at 05:16 PM.
Maybe Epice Marine or L'humaniste?
Perhaps Millesime Imperial?
Sweet and salty? That's a toughie
Sel de Vetiver or Fleurs de Sel would be my choices. Maybe Montauk although that is a bit pricey.
I agree with you about the Hermes Jardin line -- not one I've liked
Imaginary Authors falling into the sea.
It's basically = Sel marin + Litchi + grapefruit
Get a hold of a sample and try it.
Hypocrites will always be a thorn in my back....and my middle finger will always be the best remedy.....
Maybe Creed's Virgin Island Water, but thats more sea breeze with creamy coconut than watery citrus.
The only other thing I can suggest is L'eau D'Issey Summer 2014, its light, its grapefruit citrus with some calone style saltiness.
Its AdG Essenza without the woody ending. It doesnt last as long however.
Its tough to find what you're looking for.
I have zero experience with this scent, but its recommended regularly here:
L`Humaniste by Frapin
If a Creed were to be considered I'd suggest Erolfa
Try the reg Bvlgari Aqva? - not the marine?
Also another Creed possibly to be considered: Royal Water.
Guys, I didn't mention, but I have tried Millesime Imperial. I was so excited for the sample because it sounded like a perfect fit.
Unfortunately, I don't know if it's a batch thing people here talk about or what, but after a promising salty watermelon opening it goes into what I could only describe as some kind of dissonant leather or tar note. Tried 3 separate times, had to scrub it off each time. Such a shame.
Armani Code Sport Athlete, I own it and love it.
On fragrantica many people say its similar to Dior Cologne 2013. Smells a little salty a little sweet, aquatic, and just a hint of mint. Midrange pricewise. Excellent performance.
The downside: its discontinued and a little hard to find at times.
I would go with Bergamatto Marino. Another good one is Erolfa by Creed.
You are describing Erolfa. The longer I own it the better I like it.
Agree with several others here: Creed Erolfa fits the description perfectly. Sample, at least.
Like others have suggested, Erolfa would be my suggestion.
Current Top 10:
Creed Green Irish Tweed
Creed Silver Mountain Water
Creed Royal Oud
Creed Millesime Imperial
Tom Ford Tuscan Leather
Tom Ford Amber Absolute
Tom Ford Italian Cypress
Serge Lutens Ambre Sultan
Bleu de Chanel
YSL Rive Gauche Pour Homme
I agree that Erolfa fits the description.
Also try all the other Bvlgari Aqva flankers - Toniq, Marine Toniq, Amara. One of those may fit your needs.
Also, a couple that check most boxes (except salty):
L'eau par Kenzo
Versace Pour Homme
Not exactly aquatic (but has some fresh/aquatic qualities), but check out Allure Edition Blanche. I think it checks many of your boxes too. I even get a nice light vetiver in the base that can come across salty-like at times. LOVE this one.
Last edited by Tarheel Golfer; 11th June 2014 at 07:33 PM.
For Sale:Gucci Pour Homme II , Amouage Attar,Lubin Idole http://www.basenotes.net/threads/313...dwide-Shipping
Remember that while it is perfectly acceptable to criticize the content of a post - criticizing the poster is not.
Mean spirited, nasty, snide, sarcastic, hateful, and rude individuals don't warrant or deserve other individuals' acknowledgement or respect.
Another for the original Bvlgari Aqva Pour Homme. For a designer, it's an excellent impression of salty ocean water with some sweetness from the mandarin. It mellows out to light citrusy/powdery scent. It's becoming a favorite summer scent for me.
I've tried the Versaces (Pour Homme, Eau Fraiche) and didn't like them, however that particular Kenzo I have not tried and it's a good suggestion. Finally, I have tried AHEB and liked it, though to me smelled like a creamy lemon but didn't so much evoke the qualities I'm seeking here.
Gents, thanks for all the other suggestions thus far. Clearly Erolfa is one I need to try, as well as a few other suggestions. Although discontinued, Armani Code Sport Athlete is still around on Strawberrynet should it fit the bill. Funny thing: I sold my 200ml Bergamotto Marino for dirt cheap just before supplies dwindled and price spiked around the world.
I have not tried the Toniqs. Even though they have been out for a while I've never found a tester in my area. However, I love the original Aqva so much I'm considering blind buys of them. I think the chances of me disliking them completely is slim, but could be a waste of money if they aren't much different than the originals.
Amara I have tried. I first smelled it on a test strip and wrote it off as boring/not necessary/not for me. I went back later and sprayed some on my hand and really enjoyed it. It is like a softer version of the original, but still really nice.
It reminded me of an important lesson. Don't always trust what a fragrance smells like on paper.
I just recently picked up a bottle of Bond no 9's newest frag Shelter Island and I gotta say, it's pretty fantastic. I know, I know, it's a Bond so the most Basenoters won't even pretend to give it a try, but it's a great salty ocean type of a frag. To me it smells like a rustic island...what I mean by that is that it's definitely not tropical. It has an undiscovered, undeveloped remote island feel. It's got a touch of oud in it which really works great to create that feel. I'm not an oud fan, but this one is done well. Just another suggestion to add to your list.
I like South Water very much and also Lili Bermuda Calypso, but I agree with the suggestion for Falling Into the Sea by Imaginary Authors. I own all three and love each of them for different reasons.
Bvlgari Aqva Toniq - a lighter, crisper version of the original
I often bolster its performance by adding two sprays of the original Aqva
If Millesime Imperial is out of the budget, check out Sean John Unforgivable or Ed Hardy Love and Luck. To be honest, MI sounds exactly what the OP is looking for in a fragrance.
Can I suggest Lacoste Noir.
"Thank GOD for the nose, for without it we would not be enjoying these beautiful created Scents" also Remember "Balance is everything and the key to appreciating "
Millesime Imperial by Creed matches the profile pretty much to the letter. While expensive at retail, it can be found at discounters like Fragrancenet for less than half price. Maybe go into a department store that sells it just to see how well it fits with your needs. I think you'll be pleased.
Pioggia Salata by Il Profvmo (I find it horrible but it fits the family).
My current top five:
Rιminiscence - Noir
Dior - Jules
Domenico Caraceni - 1913
Charenton Macerations - Christopher Street
Dior - Eau Sauvage (vtg)
My sales thread | Evody Bois Secret, Gucci PH, Shiseido Basala (deo), Ungaro II...
My fragrance reviews | Ye Olde Civet Cat
best suggestions from those you haven't tried are:
Sel d' Vetiver by The Different Co.
Darwin by Fueguia 1833
My current top 10 fragrances :
1. Amouage Jubilation XXV
2. A Lab on Fire Almost Transparent Blue
3. YSL L'Homme Libre
4. Tauer Perfumes L'Air du Desert Marocain
5. Rania J. Ambre Loup
6. Atelier Cologne Cedrat Enivrant
7. Parfum MDCI Ambre Topkapi
8. Imaginary Authors Memoirs of a Trespasser
9. Heeley Sel Marin
10. by Kilian Back to Black
Stay away from Womanity. It's VERY beachy, VERY salty, VERY gross.
Funny, I noted in the MI thread that I had a similar experience with my sample of MI. I think it was either an issue with the sample I had (and possibly yourself), or it didn't play well with my skin. I could smell melon for the first 20 seconds or so and then this rotten scent came out, my girlfriend was disgusted as well.
When I can make time to go down to Neimans this is going to be one of the first things I check. It's been driving me nuts.
Had same issue with MI. After the opening in turns into something I'd describe tarry and earthy. Exactly same thing happens all the time with my bottle of GIT. When asked here, I was told that it's probably ambergris, the signature Creed drydown. It ruins both MI and GIT for me.
Salty sea air = Sel de Vetiver
How about Montale- Soleil de Capri? Beach and sunshine, lasts and doesn't change.
See my blog; http://www.basenotes.net/blogs/2645-kumquat
MI starts off great for the first 20-30 seconds, and then turns into some rotten nasty funk. I love the first 20-30 seconds though, lol. I'm going to break out my sample when I get home and see what happens.
Another vote for South Water.
Kenzo pour Homme
Well, You should try Salvador Dali Laguna: Slightly Salty and sweet. Simple and cosy.
For something more fresh, Hugo Boss Pure (you can't go wrong with it, although It has longevity issues)
Maybe you like Horizon, though it's more herbal-fresh than salty...........
Best fitting your description imo is the regular Bvlgari Aqva.
My Top '10' : (In no particular order)
- Dolce & Gabbana: Pour Homme (vintage)
- Paco Rabanne: Pour Homme (vintage)
- Loewe: Esencia/Pour Homme/Solo/7
- Davidoff: Leather Blend Edp
- Dior: Eau Sauvage Parfum
- MPG: Santal Noble
- Guerlain: Vetiver
- Van Cleef & Arpels: Pour Homme
- Hermes: Terre d'Hermes
- YSL: Kouros (Fraicheur)
One that rarely gets mentioned, that's high quality and meets all of your expectations is Lanvin Oxygen for Men. I think it may be what you're looking for.
My Current Top 10:
Rive Gauche Light (2004)
Paul Smith Man (2009)
Burberry London (2006)
Prada Amber pour Homme (2006)
Live Jazz (1998)
Eau des Baux (2006)
Midnight in Paris EDP (2010)
Arpege pour Homme (2005)
Eau Duelle (2010)
I think it was already mentioned but I'll put it out there again.
Tommy Bahama St. Barts
If you do get it, you will need to give it a couple of wearings. Don't put it on after you have been smelling one of your other frags during the day. I found that other scents don't meld well into this one. Putting it on fresh out of the shower is a totally different experience.
Kenzo Pour Homme.