I haven't tried Black but I have sampled both Silver and Gold a number of times. I do not like either of them, and based on my experience I do not hold much hope of Black being any better.
I have commented on these in an older thread. They just do not smell good to me, being too harsh, too chemical, too synthetic. My sampling was a case of liking them well enough at first but gradually disliking them the more I sampled them. eventually becoming completely turned off by them.
I've read where some people compare them with Montale, and I disagree. They do not smell like Montale fragrances. I am not a Montale fan, but the Mancera fragrances are way worse than the Montales.
But if possible try them for yourself. They may appeal to you.