Clive Christian ...

**johnjohn** · 15th May 2011, 06:08 PM

X, 1872 , #1 , anyone have any experience and input for the above mentioned ?

Would be neat if a few of us would get in on a decant experience.

Cold , nasty day here in NiagaraFalls. Out in the back with the dogs , cutting wood , wearing Musc Ravageur and sipping on good strong black coffee .

Does it get any better than this ? Oh, and chatting with a bunch of great BN'rs !

Regards,

John

**StylinLA** · 15th May 2011, 06:45 PM

Yes, I have tried the Clive Christian sampler pack which is about 10ml of each scent. My Nieman Marcus has a very aggressive CC rep who I have known for years from other frag counters. She nearly tackles me every time I go in there.

Number One is an over the top masculine floral kind of thing. It DOES smell expensive. It's nice, it's masculine, but I don't need to smell that way enough to pay the super outrageous price. In personality it reminds me a bit of Amouage Gold. I ain't that rich and don't need to smell that rich. Kind of leans formal. I wouldn't say you need a tux, but it would sure seem odd with jeans or khakis for sure. I know some here wear anything with anything, but this kind of calls for sartorial support imo. And a Bentley.

X for Men I liked enough to re-buy- after debating it for two years. It's very warm and sensual; very. Heavy load of cinnamon when it drys down. Gets attention. Outrageous price too, but after two years of knowing I wanted it, I finally treated myself. (Trying to find other scents that smelled like X was the reason I became a Basenoter- though I didn't post any "what smells like X for Men" threads...just poked around a lot).

1872 I just don't like. My nose couldn't wrap around anything. Others may like it a lot. I didn't hate it...just wasn't taken with anything about it. I guess it's kind of their gourmand?

FYI johnjohn, I think they tend to frown on soliciting splits in this part of the forum.

**Scentologist** · 15th May 2011, 07:52 PM

I admit its been a while since I've smelled them and want to revisit. My impression years ago was that the brand was not bottle worthy for the price. I need to reevaluate but thats where I stand for now.