First up is the Vintage EDT. I applied two sparys to my forearm, and on first application, it smells perhaps darker, and spicier/mustier than the new formula. Oddly enough though I get a lighter feeling wearing the Vintage EDT (VEDT from now on), probably because it doesn't come off as sharp initially (which was bothersome in my testing of the newer formula). To me, the VEDT smells older, and more mature. I get more of the tobacco in this formulation than I do the new one, but it is not unpleasant or cigarette like, and I think it combines nicely with the Vetiver note. However, it makes the VEDT feel less green to me when compared to the newer formula.
More to come as I discover my thoughts.