Given your liking for Lyric, I'd say that you like your rose, or your flowers, in a natural, but clean and radiant manner, more modern in style and supported by woody ambers or other dry materials. Rose 31 is more a spicy (and I don't really love it). I do love Black oud, but it's a completely different thing, a powerful, in your face synthetic oud - dark and brooding. None of the luminosity of PoL.
You might like Larimar's favorite, En Avion extrait, which is not primarily a rose, but it's floral and shares some of the dry leatheriness with PoL.