I need opinions! I'm an avid fragrance collector, and I'm looking to finally add an Oud fragrance to my collection. I have a few fragrances with Oud in it i.e. , but I want a fragrance that's OUD DOMINANT. I have Oud Immortel by Byredo which its notes deliver an Oud-like fragrance, but it officially doesn't even have any Oud in it! So... any suggestions?!
Possibilities to name a few include:
Tom Ford Oud Wood
Creed Royal Oud
By Killian Pure Oud
L'Artisan Al Oudh
My personal faveourite at the moment is : MONA Di ORiO's ~ OUD ... It's gorgeous ! ( And it's actually the real deal authentic agarwood oil that she uses , and not a man-made accord).
Lots of Montale fragrances... top notch!
LOST! in scent and music
Montale's Original Aouds comes to mind, unless you go straight for one of the authentic oils.
The Bark Bites Back.
Tom Ford Oud Wood and Montale Dark Aoud are my favourites.
For a western perfume with oud, I'd stick to Montale (Black Aoud, Aoud Lime, Oud Cuir d'Arabie, etc). I also own the Tom Ford, which seem nice and straightforward, if expensive.
I haven`t tried Tom Ford Oud Wood yet, but among the other 3, I prefer Creed Royal Oud. A smooth, spicy, sweet oud.
Dior Leather Oud and Bond No. 9 Swarovski Limited Edition are both supposedly solid oud scents (not sure they'd classify as oud dominant).
Oh yeah - welcome to basenotes, eMCizzle.
Oriscent 3000 pure Borneo Oud oil is the easiest Oud to appreciate from a western perspective.
I have not tried L'artisans offering, but the others I have tried, and out of those I would definitely say that I prefer Creed Royal Oud. Pure Oud oils are one of the things that got me into this hobby, I own several from some of the wider known purveyors. As an experiment, I wore RO with a pure Oud oil from oriscent, can't remember which one right now, and it did not really change the character or scent of it. I have tried several from Montale, with the most recent being Black Aoud, and they, IMO, are synthetic, also Montales pairing of it and their asserting synthetic loud rose accord, makes me feel like I have tiny bugs crawling on me. Mona Di orio's offering sounds interesting though.
Last edited by PEARL; 27th January 2012 at 10:05 PM.
First of all I would say it doesn't really matter if there is no oud in the fragrance. I'm a big fan of 'oud' perfumes although I'm sorry to say I've never smelled the famous Montale ouds as they don't stock them in the UK. So anyway here are my views.
The one I know best is Oud 27 as I own it.
I think it's absolutely amazing and it's probably my favourite fragrance. It goes on very sour and slightly bitter (with a faint hint of urine perhaps) then dries down to cedar wood and saffron. Most of the oud fragrances are matched with saffron or Safraleine (an aroma chemical). My son hates it with a vengeance and one or two of my friends also dislike it - but some adore it. I think it's a masterpiece.
I aslo recommend Dior Leather and Oud
It has great depth and honeyed, beewaxy resonance. Absolutely fantastic and incredibly powerful.
Another one I really like is Al Oudh
This is also superb but more herbal than the others with lots cumin. Again, apparently it has no oud in it but don't let that put you off
Montales, but is not real oud, as the others that you asked. Real ouds from Western are expensive and very different
Black Aoud is the only one for me.
A bunch of Montales (Original Aoud, Aoud Cuir D'Arabie, Aoud Musk, Dark Aoud, Red Aoud) plus Epic Man, Homage, Ormonde Man and Black Tourmaline. Obvisouly we talk about western interpretations of oud.
I love Tom Ford Oud wood and I have a bottle of the Dior Leather Oud which I love even more but find almost unwearable at my office. It's almost like lighting up an incense pot lol. Both very nice and very Oudy !
“Perfume is like cocktails without the hangover, like chocolate without the calories, like an affair without tears, like a vacation from which you never have to come back.”
They are pretty awesome and well worth trying to get hold of samples at least... I'm in the UK too, and took a risk with blind buys direct, and I'm so glad I did. Not bad at all for the price. £45 for 50ml is great for the quality of them.I've never smelled the famous Montale ouds as they don't stock them in the UK
LOST! in scent and music
Of the mainsteams, I like Al Oudh too, but you need to give a try to Ava Luxe! There are several to choose from and almost all of them are great!
Homage by Amouage followed by Harrods Swarovski Crystal Oud Edition by Bond No. 9
"Seize opportunity by the beard for it is bald behind"
The best western interpretation of oud that actually resembles what oud smells like is : (in no particular order)
Extreme Oud by Kilian but thats launched only for the UAE market. The next best thing would be Pure Oud also by Kilian.
I'm no oud expert...Igor will be along presently.
But my understanding of most of the scents you're referencing is that it isn't a true oud note, it's a synthetic. But for me, that's no reason to not try them. Those are all good scents.
From a standpoint of long lasting oud-like notes in a conventional scent, I think the Montales are best in my experience. The oud in By Killian seemed pretty prominent too. Dark Aoud is my favorite from Montale.
The Mona di Orio referenced above DOES evidently contain real oud, and the price reflects that.
Everything you referenced are good scents, with varying degrees of oud-ness.
But the oud notes in Al Aoud, Royal Oud and Oud Wood aren't very prominent. Try a Montale.
Re-reading your original post, if you want a scent with Honest to God REAL Oud in it, Mona di Orio may be the only one. Other than that, you'd need to check real ouds. Nothing is more Oud dominate than real Oud.
Last edited by StylinLA; 22nd September 2011 at 06:05 AM.
M. Micallef Homme (also known here simply as Aoud) is another good one. It is Euro-oud, but made in more of a Middle Eastern style than most.
My favorite oud based scents:
Micallef Aoud Homme: A nice, refined (some will interpret this as discrete or shy.. fair enough!) aoud + rose with a large dose of honey over a base of woods and spice.
Bond Harrods Swarovski Ltd. Edition: A green/leathery oud and vetiver with a noticeable dark myrrh note as well.
Bond New York Oud: Another aoud/rose/honey blend like Aoud Homme, but here it is paired with fruit (plums) and an acidic and bitter orange note (a really nice use of orange - it smells more like orange peel than orange, which makes sense I suppose as the listed note is "orange zest"). Also present is a hint of leather and vetiver, and in the far background a bit of iris. It's a bit more synthetic than the above two, but it's more daring, interesting, and altogether extroverted than the comparatively introverted Micallef Aoud.
Al Oudh: Smells like some oud chips I have - not the same smell as oud oils at all! This is dark, deep, and quite animalic. Moderate sillage but great longevity. One of the darkest/inkiest scents I've smelled. Dark dark reds draped in black.
I'm not a fan of the Montale ouds at all. :\
Iris Pallida 50ml
Ungaro I 75ml
and more! - http://www.basenotes.net/threads/301...n-Man-and-more
Please feel free to check out my Swap Thread - Patou pour Homme, L'Instant de Guerlain PH Extreme, Dior Homme Intense, Pure Malt, Pure Coffee and many more! Click Here For My Swap Thread
As a lover of pure oud oils I've learned to differentiate and appreciate "oud" perfumes from pure oud oil. I can't say any oud perfumes are pure oud dominant. There are some that are really nice and have strong synthetic oud in them. My favorite is Harrods Swarovski which I just got recently in the non-crystal bottle, I bought this directly from the Bond flagship store in New York. Also Dior Leather Oud is nice.
Oriscent, AgarAura Pure Ouds, Creed, LIDGE, Patou Pour Homme, tons of niche and rare stuff for sale!
As for oud-themed Western fragrances (that may or may not contain actual oud) I'd say try to find Muthhela Agallocha Man which to me stands head and shoulders above the multitudes of barely different Montales that aim to imitate traditional Middle Eastern mukhallats (pefume blends) rather than actual oud. Tom Ford's Oud Wood would be a distant second on my list although I understand that a far less expensive copy of it produced by Surrati can be had for far less. Pue Oud by Killian is neither oud nor pure but misleading name and absurd price aside it's not an unpleasant fragrance.
I would try and sample both the well-known oud-themed synthetics mentioned on this thread and at least a couple of good pure oud oils like Oriscent Borneo 3000 or Kyara Koutan before settling for a fragrance just because it gets a lot of positive coverage on Basenotes. There have been many threads on oud vs "oud" here over the last few months with a lot of different perspectives and interesting discussions, you may want to do a quick search and check them out - they should prove very helpful in your research.
Amouage Homage Attar
Amouage Epic Man
Bond 9 NY Oud
Montale Black Aoud
My Top 10
1. Amouage Homage Attar
2. Serge Lutens - Muscs Koublai Khan
3. YSL M7
4. Serge Lutens - Ambre Sultan
5. Chanel Egoiste
6. 24 Gold by Scentstory
7. Amouage Epic Man
8. Amouage Jubilation XXV
9. Bond No. 9 New York Oud
10. Serge Lutens - Chergui
"A beautiful fragrance to the nose is like good jazz music to the ears, great food to the mouth, and Megan Fox and Jessica Alba to the eyes..."
Oud27, different, wearable, very raunchy. me likes.