I don't like overly sweet either, and that is the problem I have with Ambre Narguilé as well-- along with most amber fragrances.
You might try État Libre d'Orange Jasmin et Cigarette. Not quite the same as tobacco maybe but it's the smell you get when you first open a pack of cigarettes (my dad smoked, not I), with a jasmine that is easy to wear. I know it sounds a bit weird but it works.