I don't get the resemblance at all with Fierce but to me this smells almost exactly like Woods (reformulation) only better quality. I also don't detect any peppermint really, just the same soapy vibe I get from Woods.
fierce to me is mainly sweet citrus and musk while PE is clean musky and woody
There is a frag at abercrombie kids (what the hell little kids need cologne for i dont know) that is an exact ripoff of PE. Called Colton or something like that.