Im really torn between these three soapy scents. Although I like all 3, you can only choose one of these.
Last edited by Nersh; 11th January 2012 at 03:04 PM.
For me, I'd be a close combat between Infusion d'homme and Mulger Cologne, but most likely I'd eventually settle on Mulger Cologne
I strongly favor Infusion d'Homme. Mugler cologne is alright/good (I own it). As for Prada Amber, I will never understand the appeal of it. I really do not like it. And the intense version of it I find repulsive.
1/ Infusion d'homme
2/ Mulger cologne
3/ Prada Amber Pour Homme
It's a toss up between MC and Prada Infusion for me.
I like all of them, Mugler, Infusion them Amber in order of preference, but i like them all
Wow, not much Amber love eh? Between the three for my collection, I chose Amber. Best longevity and I enjoy the powderiness of it.
The hunt for a Signature Fragrance is not an easy one! I see the light at the end of the tunnel!
Want to buy! "Nothing?!, well that's a first."
MC for me!
"Live in each season as it passes; breathe the air, drink the drink, taste the fruit, and resign yourself to the influences of each!" - Henry David Thoreau
I vote Mulger.
The Pradas are nice but a little mild-mannered for my liking, whereas Mugler is just fresh and sprightly. I prefer Mugler's grassy quality as well.
I've owned all three. I sold Amber and not sure I'll replace MC. Infusion is my favorite.
I prefer Prada Amber.
Ugh! this is near impossible!! I need more time!
-Cologne is the only fashionable thing that fits me! (Me, circa 1997-present)
Infusion, but I do enjoy all three.
I'm wearing amber right now. It's just really nice.
Infusion d'homme is vile, get the Mugler.
Prada Amber pour Homme
+1 for Mugler Cologne
I think if I could only have one of these I would take Mugler. Thought I think Infusion is a better made fragrance I prefer the actual scent of Prada Amber.
Mugler Cologne for me. I prefer it's green, "Irish Spring" type vibe. (I also prefer Mugler Cologne over the similar and much pricier Original Vetiver from Creed. I love OV's opening, but don't care for it's "rooty" smelling drydown. Mugler stays much fresher & cleaner).
Mugler is a far better soapy scent IMO. Try ADP Colonia Assoluta!
i tried mugler c. and didn't smell anything! it was almost nonexistent.. the slight smell i did get smelled like STEAM lol... so i have to go with INFUSION it was a very pleasant surprise at first smell and I did get a female compliment. It is a bit feminine for me though.. It smell, well exactly like iris flower.. or iris soap.. or even Coca Cola to me ha!
The only one out of those I find truly soapy is Infusion.
Cologne smells bright, light, green and grassy.
Amber just smells sweet. No resemblance to soap or 'clean' to me whatsoever.
I prefer Infusion, followed by Mugler. Dislike Amber.
All three I like the way it smells from the sprayer and upon application but all three after awhile I get tired of them on me.
Infusion D'Homme it takes less than an hour, it's too dry to my nose and it get irritating.
Mugler Cologne smells good for the first 2 or 3 hours but once the green-ness wears off it gets a real flat musky on my skin and I can't wait to scrub it off which is a problem because it has nuclear longevity on me.
Prada Amber I really do enjoy quite a bit for the top and heart so gets the most mileage out of my appreciation but even still by the time the base has rolled around I'm just glad it's done.
So I'd say none of the above. For awhile I really was into the 'clean' scents but now I haven't found one that really makes me look forward to wearing it, enjoy it throughout and glad I did by the time it's done. I guess I'm going have to find something that's interesting enough to keep my attention and also 'clean' for those times I crave that type of scent.
Infusion D'Homme hands down. Without question, the best clean, soapy scent out there.
MC 2nd and PAPH a distant 3rd.
I like Amber PH in the fall/winter and Original Vetiver in the spring/summer.
mugler if you want something lighter
amber if you want something a little bit heavier
both of these are good (not great), but may be a bit too pungent for some peoples tastes.
I don't get the whole Mugler thing. To me it has a heavy-handed artificially fresh vibe.
Have you ever compared German coffee to French or Italian? Sorta like that.
Infusion rules, with class.
Mugler smells like fairy liquid. I love it. But I do hate having to bathe in the stuff just to get a faint whiff for a few hours.
Current Top Five:
1. Creed Green Irish Tweed
2. Tom Ford Neroli Portofino
3. Hermes Concentre d'Orange Verte
4. Bond No. 9 New Haarlem
5. Creed Original Vetiver
Top notes of... sweat, gasoline, motor oil; a heart of deer musk and gunpowder, resting on a base of sex and testosterone... Mandom.
I love Prada Amber PH. Its got amazing longevity, and such a pleasant scent.