I'd go with Gucci Pour Homme I
Comme De Garcons 2 Man
Gucci Pour Homme I
Given a small difference in price between CDG 2 Man or Gucci Pour Homme I, which is the better (objectively) fragrance for the same price? I haven't had the opportunity to smell CDG, but I love all the stages of Gucci Pour Homme (including the "pencil shaving" note) and was told CDG2M was a good replacement. Could anyone recommend a pick or tell me how vastly different they are to one another?
I'd go with Gucci Pour Homme I
I like what CDG does, I own Hinoki. I really really wanted to like 2 Man, but I sampled it a few times and I was disappointed. Not purchase worthy at all. I'd have to recommend Gucci Pour Homme I.
Are they around the same quality then? I don't know how CDG smells but it's easier to purchase...
both are great , but CdG 2 man is more special!
my current top five (always in transition)
Dior Eau Noire
HdP 1725 Casanova
eau de gloire parfum d'empire
Dia man Amouage
comme des garçons man 2
Out of these two, I'd take Comme De Garcons 2 Man
I'd go with CdG Man 2 because Gucci PH I is very moody when it comes to longevity and projection. Sometimes it's great, sometimes it's shy, at least in my case.
Pros: both pretty much indentical with minor differences. The Gucci comes in a spectacular, grand, heavy chunky bottle.
Comme De Garcons 2 Man : bottle lies flat on the shelf like a flat fish
Gucci pour homme: deleted - but still obtainable
CdG 2 MAN
Please feel free to check out my Swap Thread - Patou pour Homme, L'Instant de Guerlain PH Extreme, Dior Homme Intense, Pure Malt, Pure Coffee and many more! Click Here For My Swap Thread
I own both. I like both. I've gone through a couple bottles of the Gucci. But when it runs out I won't replace it. They are really similar; if you have one, I don't think you need both, at least in my opinion. But...Cdg 2man is in my opinion better because: it has surpassing longevity spray for spray, surpassing projection spray for spray, CdG 2man's smoke is of high quality and CdG 2man's candlewax note gives it a more interesting dimension. +1 CdG
CdG 2 Man for me!!! I do Love Gucci PH but prefer CdG @ Man!!!
I voted 2Man as well. They're both very good, but I get more unusual notes from the 2Man, like candlewax and mahogany, whereas GpH uses more traditional perfume notes to very good effect. So if you're looking for something a little more unique and unusual, it's gotta be the CDG.
I love both and can't choose.
CDG2Man hands down. I quite like the Gucci as well but sometimes I find its strongly synthetic woody-ambery base a bit annoying...
Discover my Guest Reviewer Of The Day here
I'm interested to try new and more unique fragrances, and the iris in CDG2 is kind of intriguing to me, I just have no idea what the main differences are. Is it\does it smell like a niche fragrance or more on the designer side? Maybe compared to Chanel or Guerlain?
CDG 2 Man, I love both fragrances, but GPH I lacks the longevity and sillage of CDG 2 Man
For me, Gucci Pour Homme. It's richer, more complex, and has more natural elements in the mix. Not to mention it seems to last longer on me than the CdG. Comme des Garcons 2 Man shares a similar frankincense note to the one in the first part of GpH's development, so I understand why everyone compares them, but for me the overall experience of the two fragrances is quite different. GpH feels warm, suave, and later, sweet and comfortable. CdG 2 Man is more remote, more shamelessly synthetic, and its lemon-waxiness is just odd to me. The fragrance can feel a bit keening. I don't dislike it, but I admire it from afar more than I want to cuddle up to it. That may change with time, of course, but for me, CdG 2 Man is an art project, and GpH is a warm friend.
Comme des Garcon. In addition to what's already said, it can be super versatile, makes a great every day scent as well as one for occasions, depending on the wearer's personality and taste. It's also great for layering, which makes it fun to wear in my opinion.
Gucci Pour Homme for me!
"Live in each season as it passes; breathe the air, drink the drink, taste the fruit, and resign yourself to the influences of each!" - Henry David Thoreau
Comme des Garcons 2 Man
I don't think you can go wrong with either one. I prefer Gucci PH I, because it works better with my skin chemistry. To me CdG 2 Man has a better opening but it loses its momentum more quickly. Gucci lasts for me.
If money isn't a concern, I'd certainly go with CdG2M.
"The most beautiful sea hasn’t been crossed yet. The most beautiful child hasn’t grown up yet. The most beautiful days we haven’t seen yet. And the most beautiful words I wanted to tell you... I haven’t said yet…"
-Nazim Hikmet Ran
I love botH but i prefer Gucci pour Homme