Would be interested to find out, too. 30R., have you tried either of them?
My recent rose craving: FM Lipstick Rose + AG Ce Soir Ou Jamais + Caron Sacre + PG13 Brulure de Rose, someting old-fashioned, sweet, powdery, dusty, but NONE of these four. The closest to what I imagine in my head would be HdP 1976 Mata Hari, of all I have smelled as of late.
I was hoping about L'Occitane Rose Jardin Delice, but do not have a way of trying it, either.