Any thoughts on Trish McEvoy's Black Rose Oud? I know, I know.........

[odioustoilet]

is there not enough OUD posts out there?

Well, I figure I'd throw another OUD release into the whole mix/debate.

[thebeck]

I thought it was decent. I enjoyed wearing a sample a couple of times, but nothing remarkable enough to warrant buying a bottle.

My bottle worthy oud blends:

Mona di Orio
Oud Luban
Gao
Al Khatt
Zafar
Fars
Rose Oud - By Kilian

[hednic]

but nothing remarkable enough to warrant buying a bottle.

Agree.

[hedonist222]

Very nice. A lush and real rose with some very good oud.

[andregooren]

I was pleasantly surprised by it. I would never purchase a bottle but it was nice to come across an interesting fragrance at a department store. I have a sample tucked away somewhere...

[odioustoilet]

thanks for the input!

[runstile]

I have sampled it and it is very nice, a bit powdery on the rose for my taste (and masculinity), but would be a great feminine scent.