Hello, this is my first real post here. I'm looking to round out my collection with a rose fragrance. I love rose and have tried several, but finding just the right one can be tricky. I would like a fresh, natural, watery green rose, maybe even a little spicy

These are the ones I've tried-and why I didn't like them

Sa Majeste La Rose -Very natural, but too short lived and dried down to a dead rose.
Bvlgari Rose Essentielle - too fruity, with berries I hate berries
Heely Hippie Rose - too dirty/ animalic
Rossy de Palma Eau de Protection - too musky and personal
Chloe L'Eau de Chloe - nice, crsip, but a tad too synthetic

Any suggestions?