Hey, I have both actually. Haha, um both are VERY fresh so either one is not going to last too long. Although I was surprised when Un Jardin Sur le Nil gave me about 4 hours! I also enjoy it more than EdPR, it reminds me of a trip I took to the French countryside and the garden I visited. Much better purchase in my opinion, plus it gets so much more hype! But its really up to you.