Bois des Iles
Thread: Top Notch Sandalwoods?
What is everyones input on your favorite sandalwood. So far mine is Santal 33 by Le Labo. Really great stuff, but now I need others to compare it to....any suggestions?
Bois des Iles
Last edited by Duke Hunt; 10th July 2012 at 10:12 AM.
Real Mysore Sandalwood (e.g. from La Via del Profumo)
Chanel Bois des Iles Extrait
Creed Bois de Santal (hard to find)
Floris Sandalwood vintage (the vintage is fantastic, the new stuff purely synthetic)
DSH Sandalo Inspiritu (discontinued)
Chanel Egoiste is pretty decent for a mainstream scent
And perhaps Lutens Santal Majuscule will be a pleasant surprise...
Sandalwood by Crabtree&Evelyn
Try Bois des Iles by Chanel.
And, relative to Santal 33 by Le Labo, albeit the base borders on being too sweet and artifical, I must respect the other stages of development, and, resultantly, I give it an unenthusiastic "Thumbs Up" rating.
Creed had two sandalwoods that were very good but are now rare to "hard to find".
Best ever sandalwood: Bois de Santal - some believe this to actually have some Mysore oil in it and I would not doubt it as it is very potent. BdS has been discontinued and is all but impossible to find. I have not seen it sold in full bottles/flacons. Some still offer it in samples/small decants.
Santal Imperial - This is a very good sandalwood from Creed and I believe can still be found in the 2.5 oz bottles via Niemans online. When they are gone, they're gone.
With regard to Creed Original Santal, it cannot be compared to the two above......IF sandalwood is the fragrance you're looking for. In fact, I don't smell sandalwood at all in OS.
Montale Santal De Mysore
I should have also mentioned I have a 10 ml sample of vintage Bois des Iles EDT coming my way soon, maybe some time this week. Looking forward to trying this one, plus if I like it ill have a chance to buy a much larger amount.
Here are a some of my favorites...
Bois Des Iles
Maitre Parfumeur Et Gantier Santal Noble
Testa Maura Acqua Di Casta
Caswell Massey Sandalwood
Discover my Guest Reviewer Of The Day here
The only two Sandalwoods I've sampled are Sables and Original Santal. Sables is a strong pungent obvious sandalwood which later dies down the next day (yes the next day) into a creamy vanilla sandalwood. It is also probably more suitable to an older mature guy. Original Santal on the other hand is a very fresh take on sandalwood. The sandalwood isn't so obvious and it extremely well blended and easier to wear. This could be worn by a younger guy and pretty much day or night. Both should probably be worn in winter, especially Sables. I cannot imagine what it would be like in the summer. OS on the other hand has almost got that typical Creed freshness to it. Both are sample worthy.
MPG Santal Noble, Creed Original Santal and Chanel Bois des Iles are my favorites.
Creed Original Santal
You'll have to sell a kidney, but Xerjoff Richwood is pretty potent stuff.
MPG Santal Noble is by far my favorite sandalwood fragrance. While the_good_life is right about Floris Eau de Santal being synthetic, I still enjoy that one as well.
I don't know many Sandalwoods. I suspect that some synthetic sandalwoods are to strong and sweet for me - maybe it's just my nose. However there are some sandalwoods I love, which are:
Bois des Iles by Chanel
Egoiste by Chanel
Champagne de Bois by Sonoma Scent Studio
Egoiste, Serge Lutens Santal de Mysore.
Want to trade - Chanel Platinum Egoiste for Dior Eau Sauvage...
If you want a great sandalwood that is linear, with projection for days.... My money is Taylor of Old Bond Street- Sandalwood.
Good stuff. I was turned on to it with my Straight razor shaving soap and ASB from the same company.
"We sleep soundly in our beds because rough men stand ready in the night to visit violence on those who would do us harm." – Winston Churchill
For a nearly straight sandalwood scent, check out AoS Sandalwood. Better than the Taylor imo, but it does have a bit of a medicinal opening, which fades fairly quickly.
For less straightforward, but very good sandalwoods, there's MPG Santal Noble, Diptyque's Tam Dao, Lorenzo Villoresi Sandalo (<- a bit crazy!) and I happen to like both the Floris and Trumper's sandalwoods, although neither are really all that sandalwood-y. Also, since you can rest assured that nearly no one is making true mysore frags at this point, you may want to check some cheaper ones, too. Nandita is dirt cheap, and has both a regular sandalwood oil as well as a patchouli sandalwood oil that will both knock your socks and possibly boxers off.
Oh, and Egoiste gets an honorable mention, even though it's probably more of a rosewood accord, I'd be remiss not to recommend it at every opportunity.
Kerosene's latest fragrance, Santalum Slivers, is a really nice sandalwood scent. It's blended with some nice citrus notes as well.
Egoiste and Santal 33
Also, Santal Noble, unfortunately this one does not last long on my skin but it smells good.
1. Vintage Santal Noble by Maitre Parfumeur Et Gantier
2. Limited Edition Bois De Santal by CREED
3. Sandalo by Lorenzo Villoresi
Those are my top 3 for perfumes containing large amounts of genuine Mysore Sandalwood oil.
I also like profumum's sandalwood scent, in both formulas. And while the darker OGformula may have had more actual indian oil in it, I find the newer formula to be more friendly and approachable.
And yes, Egoiste is great, but not particularly sandalwood-centric. AOS Sandalwood is an excellent example of the drier, less buttery Australian Sandalwood oil.
Haven't yet tried Santal 33, but am quite eager to.
Egads!!! waddup Eric B !!!
BN sales: http://www.basenotes.net/threads/300...avidoff-Bombay.
Off-BN sales (super rare CREED): http://flacon.ambaric.net/viewtopic.php?t=95
This thread seems to be another reminder that I should resample Santal 33.
I'd go with Diptyque's Tam Dao and Lorenzo Villoresi's Sandalo. If Taylor of Old Bond Street's sandalwood EdT is anything like their shaving soap, it should also provide a decent reference point.
Sandalo Inspiritu (DSH) absolutely beautiful composition, sadly discontinued.
Santalum Album (La Via del Profumo), pure Mysore in alcohol EDT
Amouage Santal Attar, like a good Mysore EO with a bit of tasteful and unobtrusive support.
Bois des Iles Extrait, nice stuff, the EDT also nice but a bit 'perfumey' - if you can handle it, then fine.
Santal Noble (MPG), beautiful stuff, a desert island for me, but more of an illusory composition suggesting sandalwood
Crabtree & Evelyn Extract of Mysore Sandalwood EDT, 80's vintage - if only we knew then what we know now!
And don't discount Samsara - it's a bit clunky but it does the trick.
I wish I had tried the original Creed and Floris in their day . . .
Great lists from the previous posters, may I add just one?
I get cinnamon, cardamon and Cedar wood in my Jaipur Homme EDP - but sandalwood, not at all.
YMMV of course. But Jaipur Homme has nothing to do with sandalwood to my nose.
My favorite sandalwood frags are:
1. Le Labo Santal 33
2. DR Harris Sandalwood
3. Chanel Egoiste
Claus The Danish Viking
"When you become comfortable with uncertainty. infinite possibilities open up in your life"
-- Eckhart Tolle