I haven't tried GIT aftershave balm. But, I have 10 un-used .08 oz testers for GIT. I'm not really too fond of the fragrance as a cologne. However, I think I might mix them with unscented aftershave balm if I don't sell them on ebay. Thanks for unintentionally giving me the idea If you choose to do so, you might want to try it out as well, at least you'll know what you're getting scent wise and you'll save some cash assuming your already have a bottle of GIT.