I'm not a fan of soap, but for quality/price ratio and longevity, the best by far in your set is Mugler Cologne.
For something even cheaper, you could also get 4711, which is very cheap and smells wonderful, but doesn't last long, and reapply through the day as needed.
Another good and long lasting cheap clean/soapy frag is Anais Anais. However, it has rose, so you have to be comfortable wearing rose. Most men aren't.