Mona di Orio's Vanille
Besides what's already been recommended, try:
Seven Veils (Byredo)
Havana Vanille (L'Artisan)
Un Bois Vanille (Serge Lutens)
Vanille 44 (Le Labo)
Vaniglia del Madagascar (i Profumi di Firenze)
Mona di Orio's Vanille
+1 Dior Hypnotic Poison.
Dior Homme Intense or Caron pour un Homme
Another + on Eau Duelle. It's a great substitute for SDV if you're not crazy about the latter's boozy vibe. Also do consider Guerlain Shalimar for a little more complexity.; the vintage parfum de toilette is terrific.
Good call on Dior Hypnotic Poison too!
Doesn't get much better than S. Double Vanille IMO. Tom Ford's TV is also a nice contender.
Felanilla is a fantastic vanilla-iris-tobacco accord. Comfortable, durable, and not just a vanilla fragrance.
Mona di Orio Vanille is of course excellent, and much more of a literal vanilla than the above. The drydown isn't as interesting as the top to my nose, though.
Try Pi by Givenchy, go easy on the trigger.
Thanks everyone for the wonderful suggestions.
I own Tobacco Vanille, Jaipur Homme, Hypnotic Poison, Caron Pour Homme Impact and Pi but they're fairly neglected so I'll give them all a second look. I wear Caron Pour Homme quite a lot on the other hand and it doesn't quite satisfy, but thank you for the suggestion.
Is there that much difference between Shalimar's vintage EDP and the vintage Parfum and cologne? I own those, the parfum and cologne, but this was my great aunts favourite perfume and it's unwearable for me for that reason.
Blue Amber sounds very interesting, and I've enjoyed other Montale offerings plus the price is very much correct, btw does anyone else think Montale is actually rather cheap for 120ml's of eau de parfum? I might think a little more about Chocolate Greedy too as I've been uhming and ahing over it recently. Being able to get three Montale's for what than Double Vanille costs me is a very attractive prospect.
Will check out Les Senteurs Gourmandes Vanille Bourbon. Sounds promising, as the boozy quality of Double Vanille is one of the highlights to me (and why I layer it with 68, for extra boozy goodness)
Eau Duelle, TV, Mona Di Orio Vanilla and Baldessarini Strictly Private are on the list.
Vanille Cuir sounds interesting, but the leather could be an issue. I'll check this one out though if only for myself.
Profumum's Vanitas, Aqua di Parma Mandorlo di Sicilia and Bois 1920 La Vaniglia, all on the list as well.
Also I'll definately by checking out Myer at Pitt Street to see if they have Double Vanille for $290, amazing price from Myer of all places!
V by Valentino, L'Occitane Eau des Bavx, Serge Lutens Un Bois Vanille, Musc Ravageur, Seven Veils, Vanilia, Havana Vanille, Un Bois Vanille, Vanille 44, Vaniglia del Madagascar, Dior Homme Intense and Felanilla are all on the list as well.
You've all given me plenty to think about. Thank you!
Mona di Orio Vanille
Diptyque Eau Duelle
Kilian A Taste of Heaven
Guerlain SDV (considering the price, Eau Duelle is a better alternative imo)
These are the best from what i've tried...
There's a new Shalimar Ode a la Vanille Limited Edition coming soon - the 2010 one was exceptional, this new one features a Madagascar vanilla. Worth keeping an eye out for for those interested.
Villoresi Teinte de Neige
Eau Duelle & Eau Des Baux are excellent recommendations. Also, may wanna check out Molinard Vanille Patchouli.
My Ultimate Top 5:
24 Platinum (2012)
Burberry London (2006)
Eau des Baux (2006)
Arpege pour Homme (2005)
He Wood Silver Wind Wood has vanilla aplenty.
Thanks for the additional suggestions. I've had a chance to read reviews and look at bottles and a lot of these seem amazing. I'm honestly thinking about breaking my no decant/samples rule because lord knows buying even a quarter of these would kind of defeat the point of this being a low-cost alternative, still I'll see what I can do. In situations like this I tend to just go with whatever has the most evocative/inspiring bottle, name, notes, reviews and history.
Tom ford noir de noir???
haha..... suggestions pour out further - le labo poivre... vanilla and black pepper
I think TV is quite a good choice actually. I enjoy it! excellent sillage and longevity for sure
Current Top 5:
1. Frederic Malle L'eau d'Hiver
2. Tom Ford Noir de Noir
3. Dior Homme / Dior Homme Intense
4. Thierry Mugler A*Men Pure Havane / Pure Malt
5. Creed Aventus / Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille
You can have your cake and eat it too - just in slices!
TOP 3 hot weather:
1. Gucci Pour Homme II
2. Creed Millesime Imperial
3. Lalique Encre Noire
TOP 3 cold weather:
1. L'Instant de Guerlain Pour Homme Extreme
2. Dior Homme
3. Eau Des Baux
Another plus for SL Un Bois Vanille but also try Molinard Vanille which to my nose shares a great deal with SDV. You may need to buy direct from their website. It also vanillas up other fragrances beautifully and costs next to nothing. http://www.molinard.com/fr/articles/vanille.597.html
I can't recommend the Molinard enough
I appreciate the suggestion, but splits, decants and samples take the romance out of fragrance to me. I like to buy based on descriptions, notes, names, etc and I enjoy not knowing what I'm getting and being surprised. Even when it's a bad surprise nine out of ten times I'll develop a liking for the fragrance later.A quick plug then for our Aussie splits group!!
You can have your cake and eat it too - just in slices!
Checking out these suggestions by the way, albiet slowly.
Edit - ordered the L'Occitane and Blue Amber as well as Sweet Oriental Dream by Montale, and I'll be getting Chocolate Greedy too as soon as I find it. The great thing about these Montale Gourmands is even if I find them too much I can just give them to my fiance.
Just to note, I'm not trying to neglect your suggestions, but I'm worried about Montale's ongoing existence and want to stock up while I can. Gotta check out everything else you guys have given the nod about; I have a friend in the US who mails me fragrances so I'll hit her up and see if I can't do a bulk order for a fair price.
Out of those I own I've given Tobacco Vanille another look, but it doesn't seem to be for me although it's a good scent. I think I'm going to give it to a friend. Jaipur Homme is good, and Hypnotic Poison surprises me, feels very wearable, I might get a proper bottle because as it stands I've just got a whole bunch of minis from those Dior sets (used to sell this sort of stuff); also gave Caron Pour Homme Impact and Pi a bit more wearing. The soon-to-be-better-half doesn't like the former although I do, and though she likes the vanilla in Pi she says smelling SDV first has raised the bar too high. Alas, but I'm starting to feel the same way.
Last edited by Miket; 4th September 2012 at 02:56 AM.
Disclaimer 1: I'll avoid anything mentioned above, though Musc Ravageur warrants highlighting!
Disclaimer 2: Just including things I like.
These are in rough order of how interesting they are to me and your requirements.
Odin - Century - a woody incense vanilla; the top doesn't smack of vanilla, but it makes a beautiful appearance in short order; strangely, not included in the notes.
Jane Booke - Taken - gourmand vanilla; marketed as feminine, but I'd wear it; truly beautiful
L'Artisan - Vanilla Absolument - basically sugar cookie vanilla
Tokyo Milk - Let Them Eat Cake - like it suggests, a vanilla cake with sugary frosting
Tokyo Milk - Kabuki - a powdery vanilla
BPAL - Jareth - vanilla fougere with leather (BPAL stuff isn't typical, but feel I should include it)
BPAL - Dorian - vanilla musk; love it
Kilian - Love (Don't Be Shy) - gourmand marshmellow (hey, it has vanilla!)
Brecourt - Mauvais Garcon - woody smokey vanilla; suitable for nightlife, but elsewhere as well; a bit smokey
Parfumeria Generale - Bois Blond - a slightly musky vanilla; I personally like it, but the vanilla doesn't always come out to play
M. Micallef - Gaiac - woody vanilla
M Micallef - Note Vanillee - boozy amber vanilla