ericrico, I haven't really posted much these days; mostly I've lurked.
Your posts are usually so helpful and passionate that I had to chime in here.
The Third Man is beautiful, a dark floral that would satisfy even the fussiest nose in terms of quality. My problem with it is that it can be too pretty, and its dark & formal character make it difficult to wear regularly. It's such a black tie event type of fragrance.
Insense is brighter, and just a bit more user-friendly. I'd have no problem wearing it to work, all season, any occasion.
Both are very worthwhile additions to a collection and it really depends on what you're after.