Depends what you mean by "same juice". Most likely you wil be buying juice that was sitting around and possibly stored improperly for a few years. They then get sold to these online discount houses that dump it for a low price. That way I KNOW it wasn't sitting in a hot warehouse for a few years in some remote country before finding its way onto the Gray Market, and into my posession, where I may say "gee whats all the hype about? Doesn't smell that good to me!" If you bought the right stuff, you would know!