Jaipur Homme (EDP) by Boucheron versus Chanel Egoiste

[rlewis]

In overall scent, which is better?

[hednic]

Chanel Egoiste

[Luca]

I prefer Jaipur EdP.

[bgoc]

Needless to say it would be Jaipur EDP, king of kings.

Also, Jaipur EDP has to be the best looking bottle out there.

- - - Updated - - -

Needless to say it would be Jaipur EDP, king of kings.

Also, Jaipur EDP has to be the best looking bottle out there.

[VanAllan]

Compared to current formulation of Egoiste which literally disappeared in 3 hrs. from my skin (tested twice, in different occasions), I found Jaipur EDP longer lasting and better projecting. Regarding the scent itself as a matter of own taste, I personally prefer the EDT version over the EDP (wish I remember better how original Egoiste fills in this ranking...probably between these two).

[silverbullet]

Egoiste is my choice.

[Sandy]

I would go for Jaipur. A timeless classic both in EdP and EdT forms. Somehow I never could warm up to Egoiste.

[Duke Hunt]

Egoiste.

[rubegon]

Egoiste. I didn't think this was even a contest, but maybe I need to give Jaipur another try.

[Oslo-Fjord]

Jaipur EDP.

[ChuckW]

In my experience, Jaipur EDP is the pick. Egoiste smells nice in the bottle, but does poorly on my skin. Jaipur EDP was a real fave of mine about 12 years ago.

[Critic]

Tough call.. I'm going to go with Egoiste on this one. Simply because Jaipur EDP is so strong I get sick of it and don't feel like wearing it for months on end.

[seizetheday]

Egoiste

[sjg3839]

No question! Egoiste!

- - - Updated - - -

No question! Egoiste!

[bgoc]

[NewHaarlem]

Compared to current formulation of Egoiste which literally disappeared in 3 hrs. from my skin (tested twice, in different occasions), I found Jaipur EDP longer lasting and better projecting. Regarding the scent itself as a matter of own taste, I personally prefer the EDT version over the EDP (wish I remember better how original Egoiste fills in this ranking...probably between these two).

From my experience, the latest formulation of Egoiste develops and projects and lasts longer in the cold weather.

[Ken_Russell]

I like both, but I'd eventually choose Jaipur.

[JON RODGERS]

Enjoy both, prefer Egoiste.

[The-odor]

Dunno for vintage...
for now, Jaipur EDP by a long range

Regards, Odor.

[bgoc]

[alfarom]

Enjoy both, prefer Egoiste.

Same here.

[comfortablynumbbg]

Jaipur was extremely unpleasant when I sprayed it, too old mannish, Egoiste while not exactly my favorite I think is a better fragrance

[del]

I prefer Egoiste by Chanel.

[senore01]

Jaipur for me. Love that vanilla dry down and it really is not old man ish. Any young guy can pull it off.

[dollars&scents]

Egoiste by Chanel.

[comfortablynumbbg]

Can't believe Jaipur is actually winning this, I thought Egoiste was untouchable on this forum

[timdoeswell]

My vote for the mighty Egoiste, my favourite fragrance still in production, just tied the scores at 13-all.

[amw9490]

Dislike both.

[calilove]

Chanel Egoiste

[rubegon]

Can't believe Jaipur is actually winning this, I thought Egoiste was untouchable on this forum

You and me both. I thought it would be 100 to 3 or something.

[thatmakesscents]

Two different scents in a somewhat similar genre. You really need to smell both and decide for yourself. There is no "better" between the two IMO just different.

[Tony the Tiger]

Egoisté

[bgoc]

After reading through the posts it's clear my obsession with Jaipur EDP is valid.

[imyourhuckleberryxx]

Oh man, Jaipur EDP by a long shot for me. I only have the Platinum Egoiste but either way it would go to Jaipur EDP. Its my go to and almost signature fragrance. I have both the edt and etp and they're both great. EDT can be used year round but I usually bring it out for the warmer months. EDP inst as potent as some would make it out to be but I still pretty much use it as my winter fragrance.

[axmaster45]

Oh man, Jaipur EDP by a long shot for me. I only have the Platinum Egoiste but either way it would go to Jaipur EDP. Its my go to and almost signature fragrance. I have both the edt and etp and they're both great. EDT can be used year round but I usually bring it out for the warmer months. EDP inst as potent as some would make it out to be but I still pretty much use it as my winter fragrance.

I had a sample of Platinum Egoiste, and hated it and figured why bother with the original. What a mistake! i got a decant of Egoiste and want to wear it every day in the cool weather!

I have a decant of Jaipur Homme EDP on the way, so i cannot compare just yet!

[axmaster45]

Oh man, Jaipur EDP by a long shot for me. I only have the Platinum Egoiste but either way it would go to Jaipur EDP. Its my go to and almost signature fragrance. I have both the edt and etp and they're both great. EDT can be used year round but I usually bring it out for the warmer months. EDP inst as potent as some would make it out to be but I still pretty much use it as my winter fragrance.

I had a sample of Platinum Egoiste, and hated it and figured why bother with the original. What a mistake! i got a decant of Egoiste and want to wear it every day in the cool weather! I wore them side by side and something in the Platinum makes me sick, while the original is probably my favorite at the moment, and will be in my collection always.

I have a decant of Jaipur Homme EDP on the way, so i cannot compare just yet!

[Postumo]

I have both but I prefer Jaipur EDP by far.

[bgoc]

[Surfacing]

Perhaps a bump to allow Jaipur Homme EDP to catch up

[bgoc]

[laph]

Wow, I'm surprised Jaipur even got close. Much prefer Egoiste myself but J is very nice.