Code of Conduct
Results 1 to 18 of 18
  1. #1

    Default Rate these fragrances

    This is my collection. Please tell me what you think about each of them by giving them scores from 1-10.

    In no particular order with my ratings:
    - Boucheron Jaipur Pour Homme (EDT) (6)
    - Boucheron Pour Homme (EDT) (2)
    - A*Men (8)
    - CK One Shock (8)
    - Le Male (5)
    - Spicebomb (6)
    - 1 Million (7)
    - Givenchy Pi (8)
    - Dior Fahrenheit (8)
    - Dior Homme (vintage) (5)
    - Burberry London (7)
    - D&G The One (6)
    - D&G Pour Homme (6)
    - Armani Code (4)
    - Acqua di Gio (7)
    - Chanel Egoiste (8)
    - Chanel Allure Homme (4)
    - Chanel Allure Homme Sport (9)
    - Bleu de Chanel (8)
    - Abercrombie & Fitch Fierce (6)
    - Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) (7)
    - Cool Water (6)
    - Versace Man Eau Fraiche (4)
    - Versace Pour Homme (6)
    - The Dreamer (7)
    - YSL L`Homme (7)
    - YSL La Nuit de L`Homme (10)
    - Gucci Pour Homme II (6)
    - Ed Hardy Love & Luck (6)
    - L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme (4)
    - Tobacco Vanille (8)
    - New Haarlem (3)
    - Chez Bond (7)
    - Bleecker Street (9)
    - Riverside Drive (8)
    - Wall Street (2)
    - Creed Silver Mountain Water (5)
    - Creed Millesime Imperial (6)
    - Creed Green Irish Tweed (9)
    - Creed Aventus (7)
    Last edited by anewtypedude; 30th October 2012 at 11:12 AM.

  2. #2
    Sound Scents
    drseid's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 1970
    Location
    Northern VA/DC Area
    Posts
    6,395

    Default Re: Rate these fragrances

    Quote Originally Posted by anewtypedude View Post
    This is my collection. Please tell me what you think about each of them by giving them scores from 1-10.

    In no particular order:

    - A*Men 6
    - CK One Shock 5
    - Le Male 3
    - 1 Million 3
    - Dior Fahrenheit 9 (vintage)/7 (current)
    - Dior Homme (vintage) 6
    - Burberry London 7.5
    - Armani Code 5
    - Acqua di Gio 7
    - Chanel Egoiste 4
    - Chanel Allure Homme 5
    - Chanel Allure Homme Sport 3
    - Bleu de Chanel 4
    - Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) 9
    - Cool Water 8 (vintage)/ 6.5 (current)
    - YSL L`Homme 2
    - YSL La Nuit de L`Homme 2
    - L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme 1
    - Tobacco Vanille 8
    - Creed Silver Mountain Water 5
    - Creed Millesime Imperial 7.5
    - Creed Green Irish Tweed 8
    - Creed Aventus 6
    I put ratings next to the ones you listed in the quote above that were still fresh enough in my mind to give an opinion and deleted the rest...
    Current Top Favorites:
    1) Portrait of a Lady original formula (EdP Frédéric Malle)
    2) Giorgio for Men vintage/V.I.P. for Men (Giorgio Beverly Hills)
    3) Dia Man vintage edt (Amouage)
    4) Les Nombres d'Or Vetyver (Mona di Orio) - tie
    4) Lalfeorosa (O'driù) - tie

    6) Anat Fritz Original Formula and Classical (Anat Fritz)
    7) Captain vintage (Molyneux)
    8) Tzora (Anat Fritz)

  3. #3

    Default Re: Rate these fragrances

    - A*Men (7)
    - Le Male (6)
    - Spicebomb (8)
    - 1 Million (3)
    - Givenchy Pi (4)
    - Dior Fahrenheit (9)
    - Dior Homme (vintage) (8)
    - Burberry London (9)
    - D&G The One (4)
    - D&G Pour Homme (2)
    - Armani Code (3)
    - Acqua di Gio (3)
    - Chanel Egoiste (8)
    - Chanel Allure Homme (4)
    - Chanel Allure Homme Sport (3)
    - Bleu de Chanel (4)
    - Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) (8)
    - Cool Water (4)
    - Versace Man Eau Fraiche (2)
    - Versace Pour Homme (2)
    - The Dreamer (1)
    - YSL L`Homme (3)
    - YSL La Nuit de L`Homme (2)
    - Gucci Pour Homme II (9)
    - L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme (3)
    - Tobacco Vanille (7)
    - New Haarlem (8)
    - Chez Bond (7)
    - Bleecker Street (6)
    - Riverside Drive (4)
    - Wall Street (2)
    - Creed Silver Mountain Water (7)
    - Creed Millesime Imperial (8)
    - Creed Green Irish Tweed (8)
    - Creed Aventus (7)

    The ones I've tried


    If they are in your collection and you rate them lowly why don't you sell them and get something you do like?

  4. #4

    Default Re: Rate these fragrances

    - Boucheron Jaipur Pour Homme (EDT)
    - Boucheron Pour Homme (EDT)
    - Dior Fahrenheit
    - Dior Homme (vintage)
    - Chanel Egoiste
    - Terre D`Hermes (Parfum)
    - Cool Water
    - Creed Green Irish Tweed


    ^^^ these are the only ones I would rate positively.


    Discover my Guest Reviewer Of The Day here

  5. #5
    hednic's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    McLean, NYC, & Búzios
    Posts
    79,135

    Default Re: Rate these fragrances

    The ones below are all good ones IMO.

    Boucheron Jaipur Pour Homme (EDT)
    Boucheron Pour Homme (EDT)
    A*Men
    Le Male
    Spicebomb
    1 Million
    Givenchy Pi
    Dior Fahrenheit
    Dior Homme (vintage)
    Burberry London
    Armani Code
    Acqua di Gio
    Chanel Egoiste
    Chanel Allure Homme
    Chanel Allure Homme Sport
    Bleu de Chanel
    Terre D`Hermes (Parfum)
    Cool Water
    YSL L`Homme
    YSL La Nuit de L`Homme
    Gucci Pour Homme II
    L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme
    Creed Silver Mountain Water
    Creed Millesime Imperial
    Creed Green Irish Tweed
    Creed Aventus

  6. #6

    Default Re: Rate these fragrances

    Like
    - Boucheron Jaipur Pour Homme (EDT) (6)
    - Boucheron Pour Homme (EDT) (2)
    - A*Men (8)
    - Le Male (5)
    - Givenchy Pi (8)
    - Dior Fahrenheit (8)
    - Dior Homme (vintage) (5)
    - Burberry London (7)
    - Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) (7)
    - Cool Water (6)

    Didn't care much for
    - D&G Pour Homme (6)
    - Chanel Allure Homme Sport (9)
    - Bleu de Chanel (8)
    - The Dreamer (7)
    - L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme (4)

  7. #7

    Default Re: Rate these fragrances

    There were many fragrances not familiar to me.
    But these are my ratings:

    - Boucheron Pour Homme (EDT) (7)
    - A*Men (3)
    - Le Male (3)
    - Spicebomb (6)
    - 1 Million (8)
    - Givenchy Pi (4)
    - Dior Fahrenheit (4)
    - Dior Homme (vintage) (8)
    - Burberry London (7)
    - D&G The One (2)
    - D&G Pour Homme (8)
    - Armani Code (6)
    - Acqua di Gio (5)
    - Chanel Egoiste (7)
    - Chanel Allure Homme (4)
    - Chanel Allure Homme Sport (7)
    - Bleu de Chanel (8)
    - Abercrombie & Fitch Fierce (7)
    - Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) (5)
    - Cool Water (5)
    - The Dreamer (4)
    - YSL La Nuit de L`Homme (7)
    - Gucci Pour Homme II (8)
    - L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme (3)
    - Creed Silver Mountain Water (7)
    - Creed Green Irish Tweed (6)
    "Le parfum est la musique du corps"
    (Marcel Rochas)

  8. #8

    Default Re: Rate these fragrances

    - A*Men (3) - just so hard to get past the opening and tar note
    - Dior Fahrenheit (3) - similar to A*Men for me...smells like petrol for too long
    - Burberry London (9) - beautifully blended & perfect for colder weather - would be a 10 if it lasted longer
    - Armani Code (6) - for some reason the olive note is too strong for me & ruins it for me
    - Acqua di Gio (8) - a classic, just not one I wear
    - Chanel Egoiste (9) - a beautiful classic...would be a 10 if it the opening weren't so harsh & it were a bit more versatile
    - Chanel Allure Homme Sport (7) - I much prefer the extreme version
    - Bleu de Chanel (5) - not sure why, but the incense in Bleu just explodes off my skin way too strong & I can't handle it
    - Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) (10) - I so love this stuff!
    - Cool Water (6) - great smell, but come off as overly synthetic now that I've smelled so many others & own GIT
    - YSL L`Homme (7) - pretty nice scent
    - YSL La Nuit de L`Homme (6) - sexy fragrance, just a tad too sweet & feminine on my skin
    - Gucci Pour Homme II (9.5) - one of my favorites...beautifully blended & extremely versatile
    - Ed Hardy Love & Luck (7) - a "nice" smell to me, but nothing special
    - L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme (4) - this one just never quite "agreed" with my nose for some reason..don't really know why
    - Tobacco Vanille (9.5) - as a fragrance, to me it's a wonderful masterpiece, but I don't find it very versatile at all
    - New Haarlem (9) - another great blend, but like TV, I just don't find it that versatile
    - Bleecker Street (6) - Improves in drydown, but the 1st 1-2 hrs are sharp, sour & very chemical on my skin
    - Riverside Drive (8.5) - I really enjoy RD - one of the best bonds along with NH IMO
    - Creed Silver Mountain Water (8) - I find it a beautiful fragrance...a bit feminine on my skin, though
    - Creed Millesime Imperial (3) - sorry, but just don't get this one - all I got was chemical salt & light melon on my skin
    - Creed Green Irish Tweed (10) - my absolute favorite fragrance of all - a masterful classic & my first true fragrance love
    - Creed Aventus (10) - my 2nd favorite Creed & I love this stuff a little more each time I wear it. Soon to be a classic IMO

  9. #9

    Default Re: Rate these fragrances

    - A*Men (7)
    - Le Male (7)
    - Spicebomb (6)
    - 1 Million (7)
    - Givenchy Pi (7)
    - Dior Fahrenheit (10)
    - Dior Homme (vintage) (9)
    - Burberry London (10)
    - D&G The One (6)
    - D&G Pour Homme (7)
    - Armani Code (6)
    - Acqua di Gio (7)
    - Chanel Allure Homme (6)
    - Chanel Allure Homme Sport (6)
    - Bleu de Chanel (6)
    - Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) (7)
    - Cool Water (7)
    - Versace Man Eau Fraiche (5)
    - Versace Pour Homme (3)
    - The Dreamer (8)
    - YSL L`Homme (7)
    - YSL La Nuit de L`Homme (10)
    - Gucci Pour Homme II (7)
    - Ed Hardy Love & Luck (4)
    - L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme (3)
    - Tobacco Vanille (8)
    - New Haarlem (5)
    - Wall Street (5)
    - Creed Silver Mountain Water (8)
    - Creed Green Irish Tweed (9)
    - Creed Aventus (9)
    My 3 Signature Scents:

    Rive Gauche Light (2004)
    Fahrenheit (1988)
    Paul Smith Man (2009)

  10. #10

    Default Re: Rate these fragrances

    - Boucheron Jaipur Pour Homme (EDT) (7)
    - Boucheron Pour Homme (EDT) (N/A)
    - A*Men (8)
    - CK One Shock (6)
    - Le Male (7)
    - Spicebomb (6)
    - 1 Million (6)
    - Givenchy Pi (7)
    - Dior Fahrenheit (10)
    - Dior Homme (vintage) (8)
    - Burberry London (8)
    - D&G The One (6)
    - D&G Pour Homme (8)
    - Armani Code (7)
    - Acqua di Gio (7)
    - Chanel Egoiste (9)
    - Chanel Allure Homme (7)
    - Chanel Allure Homme Sport (8)
    - Bleu de Chanel (8)
    - Abercrombie & Fitch Fierce (6)
    - Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) (8)
    - Cool Water (7)
    - Versace Man Eau Fraiche (5)
    - Versace Pour Homme (6)
    - The Dreamer (7)
    - YSL L`Homme (7)
    - YSL La Nuit de L`Homme (5)
    - Gucci Pour Homme II (9)
    - Ed Hardy Love & Luck (7)
    - L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme (8)
    - Tobacco Vanille (8)
    - New Haarlem (6)
    - Chez Bond (5)
    - Bleecker Street (9)
    - Riverside Drive (7)
    - Wall Street (6)
    - Creed Silver Mountain Water (7)
    - Creed Millesime Imperial (10)
    - Creed Green Irish Tweed (10)
    - Creed Aventus (10)

  11. #11

    Default Re: Rate these fragrances

    Quote Originally Posted by anewtypedude View Post
    This is my collection. Please tell me what you think about each of them by giving them scores from 1-10.

    In no particular order with my ratings:
    - Boucheron Jaipur Pour Homme (EDT) (7)
    - Boucheron Pour Homme (EDT) (8)
    - A*Men (?)
    - CK One Shock (?)
    - Le Male (2)
    - Spicebomb (9)
    - 1 Million (?)
    - Givenchy Pi (5)
    - Dior Fahrenheit (?)
    - Dior Homme (vintage) (?)
    - Burberry London (7)
    - D&G The One (8)
    - D&G Pour Homme (5)
    - Armani Code (4)
    - Acqua di Gio (5)
    - Chanel Egoiste (8)
    - Chanel Allure Homme (?)
    - Chanel Allure Homme Sport (?)
    - Bleu de Chanel (?)
    - Abercrombie & Fitch Fierce (?)
    - Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) (8)
    - Cool Water (6)
    - Versace Man Eau Fraiche (?)
    - Versace Pour Homme (?)
    - The Dreamer (?)
    - YSL L`Homme (?)
    - YSL La Nuit de L`Homme (9)
    - Gucci Pour Homme II (?)
    - Ed Hardy Love & Luck (?)
    - L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme (4)
    - Tobacco Vanille (?)
    - New Haarlem (?)
    - Chez Bond (?)
    - Bleecker Street (?)
    - Riverside Drive (?)
    - Wall Street (?)
    - Creed Silver Mountain Water (?)
    - Creed Millesime Imperial (?)
    - Creed Green Irish Tweed (9)
    - Creed Aventus (?)
    inserted my ratings on those i have had time with. Boucheron PH a 2? wow i loved that stuff.

  12. #12

    Default Re: Rate these fragrances

    Nice collection!

    My ratings:
    - A*Men (7)
    - Le Male (5)
    - 1 Million (4)
    - Burberry London (6)
    - D&G Pour Homme (3)
    - Armani Code (6)
    - Acqua di Gio (6)
    - Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) (8)
    - Cool Water (3)
    - Tobacco Vanille (8)
    - New Haarlem (5)
    - Chez Bond (1)
    - Creed Silver Mountain Water (10)
    - Creed Millesime Imperial (8)
    - Creed Green Irish Tweed (10)
    - Creed Aventus (8)

  13. #13

    Default Re: Rate these fragrances

    - A*Men 8.5
    - CK One Shock 8
    - Le Male 6.5
    - Spicebomb 8
    - 1 Million 7.5
    - Givenchy Pi 8
    - Dior Fahrenheit 9
    - Dior Homme (vintage) 9
    - D&G The One 7
    - D&G Pour Homme 8
    - Armani Code 6
    - Acqua di Gio 7
    - Chanel Egoiste 8.5 (Platinum - 7.5)
    - Chanel Allure Homme 7
    - Chanel Allure Homme Sport 6
    - Bleu de Chanel 7.5
    - Abercrombie & Fitch Fierce 7
    - Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) 9.5
    - Cool Water 8
    - Versace Man Eau Fraiche 7.5
    - Versace Pour Homme 7
    - The Dreamer 8
    - YSL L`Homme 7
    - YSL La Nuit de L`Homme 8.5
    - Gucci Pour Homme II 9
    - Ed Hardy Love & Luck 7
    - L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme 8.5
    - Creed Millesime Imperial 9.5
    - Creed Green Irish Tweed 9
    - Creed Aventus 8
    -Cologne is the only fashionable thing that fits me! (Me, circa 1997-present)
    http://www.youtube.com/860cologne

  14. #14

    Default Re: Rate these fragrances

    Only rating the ones I know
    - A*Men (8)
    - CK One Shock (7)
    - Le Male (6)
    - 1 Million (7)
    - Givenchy Pi (5)
    - Dior Fahrenheit (6)
    - Burberry London (8)
    - D&G The One (9)
    - D&G Pour Homme (6)
    - Armani Code (3)
    - Acqua di Gio (7)
    - Chanel Allure Homme (7)
    - Chanel Allure Homme Sport (8)
    - Bleu de Chanel (8)
    - Abercrombie & Fitch Fierce (7)
    - Cool Water (6)
    - Versace Man Eau Fraiche (7)
    - The Dreamer (4)
    - YSL L`Homme (9)
    - YSL La Nuit de L`Homme (8)
    - Gucci Pour Homme II (8)
    - Ed Hardy Love & Luck (7)
    - L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme (4) -Summer 09 edition (8)/had to throw that one in
    - Creed Millesime Imperial (7)

  15. #15

    Default Re: Rate these fragrances

    Hall of Famers
    - A*Men
    - Le Male
    - D&G Pour Homme
    - The Dreamer
    - L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme
    - Tobacco Vanille
    - Riverside Drive
    - Creed Millesime Imperial
    - Creed Green Irish Tweed

    All-Stars
    - Creed Aventus
    - Dior Fahrenheit
    - Dior Homme (vintage)
    - Acqua di Gio
    - Chanel Egoiste
    - Abercrombie & Fitch Fierce
    - Gucci Pour Homme II
    - New Haarlem
    - Chez Bond
    - Bleecker Street

    Starters
    - Spicebomb
    - 1 Million
    - Burberry London
    - Armani Code
    - Chanel Allure Homme
    - Chanel Allure Homme Sport
    - Bleu de Chanel
    - Cool Water
    - Versace Man Eau Fraiche
    - YSL La Nuit de L`Homme
    - Wall Street
    - Creed Silver Mountain Water

    Part-Timers
    - Boucheron Jaipur Pour Homme (EDT)
    - CK One Shock
    - Givenchy Pi
    - D&G The One
    - Versace Pour Homme
    - YSL L`Homme

    Bench Warmers
    - Ed Hardy Love & Luck

  16. #16

    Default Re: Rate these fragrances

    some fragrances from your list:
    - Le Male (4)
    - Spicebomb (4)
    - Dior Homme (vintage) (10)
    - D&G The One (6)
    - Chanel Allure Homme Sport (6)
    - Bleu de Chanel (8)
    - YSL L`Homme (9)
    - Creed Silver Mountain Water (7)
    - Creed Millesime Imperial (7)
    - Creed Aventus (10)

  17. #17
    Dependent Possum-Pie's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2012
    Location
    Near Gettysburg
    Posts
    1,845
    Blog Entries
    15

    Default Re: Rate these fragrances

    - A*Men I LOVE IT, I HATE IT, I LOVE IT...
    - Spicebomb YUCK
    - 1 Million SMELLS LIKE A MILLION!
    - Dior Fahrenheit SMELLS LIKE GASOLINE/PETROL
    - Burberry London BRIT'S BETTER
    - Acqua di Gio NICE BUT EVERYONE WEARS IT
    Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) NICE
    - Cool Water LESS EXPENSIVE ALTERNATIVE TO GIT.
    - Versace Pour Homme EXCELLENT...TOP NOTCH
    - YSL L`Homme I LIKE LIBRE MORE...
    - Tobacco Vanille NICE FOR WINTER/FALL
    - Bleecker Street CHEMICAL SMELLING
    - Riverside Drive CHEMICAL SMELLING
    - Wall Street SMELLS LIKE MOWED VINES
    - Creed Silver Mountain Water GENERIC
    - Creed Millesime Imperial GENERIC
    - Creed Green Irish Tweed OVERUSED
    - Creed Aventus OVERUSED

  18. #18

    Default Re: Rate these fragrances

    Omitting the ones I've never tried:

    - A*Men (9.5)
    - CK One Shock (8)
    - Le Male (7.5)
    - Spicebomb (7)
    - 1 Million (6)
    - Givenchy Pi (7)
    - Dior Fahrenheit (9.5)
    - Dior Homme (vintage) (10)
    - Burberry London (8)
    - D&G The One (4)
    - Acqua di Gio (8)
    - Abercrombie & Fitch Fierce (6)
    - Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) (8)
    - Cool Water (5)
    - Versace Man Eau Fraiche (6)
    - The Dreamer (9)
    - YSL L`Homme (8)
    - YSL La Nuit de L`Homme (6)
    - Gucci Pour Homme II (10)
    - Ed Hardy Love & Luck (7)
    - L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme (6)
    - Creed Silver Mountain Water (10)
    - Creed Millesime Imperial (7)
    - Creed Green Irish Tweed (10)
    - Creed Aventus (9)

    - - - Updated - - -

    Omitting the ones I've never tried:

    - A*Men (9.5)
    - CK One Shock (8)
    - Le Male (7.5)
    - Spicebomb (7)
    - 1 Million (6)
    - Givenchy Pi (7)
    - Dior Fahrenheit (9.5)
    - Dior Homme (vintage) (10)
    - Burberry London (8)
    - D&G The One (4)
    - Acqua di Gio (8)
    - Abercrombie & Fitch Fierce (6)
    - Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) (8)
    - Cool Water (5)
    - Versace Man Eau Fraiche (6)
    - The Dreamer (9)
    - YSL L`Homme (8)
    - YSL La Nuit de L`Homme (6)
    - Gucci Pour Homme II (10)
    - Ed Hardy Love & Luck (7)
    - L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme (6)
    - Creed Silver Mountain Water (10)
    - Creed Millesime Imperial (7)
    - Creed Green Irish Tweed (10)
    - Creed Aventus (9)

Similar Threads

  1. Five Stars fragrances ? Rate it
    By grauzone in forum Just Starting Out
    Replies: 32
    Last Post: 9th September 2012, 02:40 PM
  2. Rate these fragrances
    By Dailey in forum Just Starting Out
    Replies: 9
    Last Post: 8th September 2012, 06:29 PM
  3. Celebrity perfumes are among the bestsellers, but how do they rate as fragrances?
    By petruccijc in forum General Fragrance Discussion
    Replies: 10
    Last Post: 12th November 2011, 06:05 AM
  4. Rate these fragrances
    By youngscholar in forum Male Fragrance Discussion
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 1st December 2005, 07:47 PM
  5. how you rate salvadore dali fragrances??
    By emad in forum Male Fragrance Discussion
    Replies: 5
    Last Post: 21st October 2005, 05:27 PM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •