Rate these fragrances

[anewtypedude]

This is my collection. Please tell me what you think about each of them by giving them scores from 1-10.

In no particular order with my ratings:
- Boucheron Jaipur Pour Homme (EDT) (6)
- Boucheron Pour Homme (EDT) (2)
- A*Men (8)
- CK One Shock (8)
- Le Male (5)
- Spicebomb (6)
- 1 Million (7)
- Givenchy Pi (8)
- Dior Fahrenheit (8)
- Dior Homme (vintage) (5)
- Burberry London (7)
- D&G The One (6)
- D&G Pour Homme (6)
- Armani Code (4)
- Acqua di Gio (7)
- Chanel Egoiste (8)
- Chanel Allure Homme (4)
- Chanel Allure Homme Sport (9)
- Bleu de Chanel (8)
- Abercrombie & Fitch Fierce (6)
- Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) (7)
- Cool Water (6)
- Versace Man Eau Fraiche (4)
- Versace Pour Homme (6)
- The Dreamer (7)
- YSL L`Homme (7)
- YSL La Nuit de L`Homme (10)
- Gucci Pour Homme II (6)
- Ed Hardy Love & Luck (6)
- L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme (4)
- Tobacco Vanille (8)
- New Haarlem (3)
- Chez Bond (7)
- Bleecker Street (9)
- Riverside Drive (8)
- Wall Street (2)
- Creed Silver Mountain Water (5)
- Creed Millesime Imperial (6)
- Creed Green Irish Tweed (9)
- Creed Aventus (7)

[drseid]

This is my collection. Please tell me what you think about each of them by giving them scores from 1-10.

In no particular order:

- A*Men 6
- CK One Shock 5
- Le Male 3
- 1 Million 3
- Dior Fahrenheit 9 (vintage)/7 (current)
- Dior Homme (vintage) 6
- Burberry London 7.5
- Armani Code 5
- Acqua di Gio 7
- Chanel Egoiste 4
- Chanel Allure Homme 5
- Chanel Allure Homme Sport 3
- Bleu de Chanel 4
- Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) 9
- Cool Water 8 (vintage)/ 6.5 (current)
- YSL L`Homme 2
- YSL La Nuit de L`Homme 2
- L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme 1
- Tobacco Vanille 8
- Creed Silver Mountain Water 5
- Creed Millesime Imperial 7.5
- Creed Green Irish Tweed 8
- Creed Aventus 6

I put ratings next to the ones you listed in the quote above that were still fresh enough in my mind to give an opinion and deleted the rest...

[starshipvelcro]

- A*Men (7)
- Le Male (6)
- Spicebomb (8)
- 1 Million (3)
- Givenchy Pi (4)
- Dior Fahrenheit (9)
- Dior Homme (vintage) (8)
- Burberry London (9)
- D&G The One (4)
- D&G Pour Homme (2)
- Armani Code (3)
- Acqua di Gio (3)
- Chanel Egoiste (8)
- Chanel Allure Homme (4)
- Chanel Allure Homme Sport (3)
- Bleu de Chanel (4)
- Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) (8)
- Cool Water (4)
- Versace Man Eau Fraiche (2)
- Versace Pour Homme (2)
- The Dreamer (1)
- YSL L`Homme (3)
- YSL La Nuit de L`Homme (2)
- Gucci Pour Homme II (9)
- L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme (3)
- Tobacco Vanille (7)
- New Haarlem (8)
- Chez Bond (7)
- Bleecker Street (6)
- Riverside Drive (4)
- Wall Street (2)
- Creed Silver Mountain Water (7)
- Creed Millesime Imperial (8)
- Creed Green Irish Tweed (8)
- Creed Aventus (7)

The ones I've tried


If they are in your collection and you rate them lowly why don't you sell them and get something you do like?

[alfarom]

- Boucheron Jaipur Pour Homme (EDT)
- Boucheron Pour Homme (EDT)
- Dior Fahrenheit
- Dior Homme (vintage)
- Chanel Egoiste
- Terre D`Hermes (Parfum)
- Cool Water
- Creed Green Irish Tweed


^^^ these are the only ones I would rate positively.

[hednic]

The ones below are all good ones IMO.

Boucheron Jaipur Pour Homme (EDT)
Boucheron Pour Homme (EDT)
A*Men
Le Male
Spicebomb
1 Million
Givenchy Pi
Dior Fahrenheit
Dior Homme (vintage)
Burberry London
Armani Code
Acqua di Gio
Chanel Egoiste
Chanel Allure Homme
Chanel Allure Homme Sport
Bleu de Chanel
Terre D`Hermes (Parfum)
Cool Water
YSL L`Homme
YSL La Nuit de L`Homme
Gucci Pour Homme II
L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme
Creed Silver Mountain Water
Creed Millesime Imperial
Creed Green Irish Tweed
Creed Aventus

[Rüssel]

Like
- Boucheron Jaipur Pour Homme (EDT) (6)
- Boucheron Pour Homme (EDT) (2)
- A*Men (8)
- Le Male (5)
- Givenchy Pi (8)
- Dior Fahrenheit (8)
- Dior Homme (vintage) (5)
- Burberry London (7)
- Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) (7)
- Cool Water (6)

Didn't care much for
- D&G Pour Homme (6)
- Chanel Allure Homme Sport (9)
- Bleu de Chanel (8)
- The Dreamer (7)
- L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme (4)

[döfä91]

There were many fragrances not familiar to me.
But these are my ratings:

- Boucheron Pour Homme (EDT) (7)
- A*Men (3)
- Le Male (3)
- Spicebomb (6)
- 1 Million (8)
- Givenchy Pi (4)
- Dior Fahrenheit (4)
- Dior Homme (vintage) (8)
- Burberry London (7)
- D&G The One (2)
- D&G Pour Homme (8)
- Armani Code (6)
- Acqua di Gio (5)
- Chanel Egoiste (7)
- Chanel Allure Homme (4)
- Chanel Allure Homme Sport (7)
- Bleu de Chanel (8)
- Abercrombie & Fitch Fierce (7)
- Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) (5)
- Cool Water (5)
- The Dreamer (4)
- YSL La Nuit de L`Homme (7)
- Gucci Pour Homme II (8)
- L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme (3)
- Creed Silver Mountain Water (7)
- Creed Green Irish Tweed (6)

[fit&frag'd]

- A*Men (3) - just so hard to get past the opening and tar note
- Dior Fahrenheit (3) - similar to A*Men for me...smells like petrol for too long
- Burberry London (9) - beautifully blended & perfect for colder weather - would be a 10 if it lasted longer
- Armani Code (6) - for some reason the olive note is too strong for me & ruins it for me
- Acqua di Gio (8) - a classic, just not one I wear
- Chanel Egoiste (9) - a beautiful classic...would be a 10 if it the opening weren't so harsh & it were a bit more versatile
- Chanel Allure Homme Sport (7) - I much prefer the extreme version
- Bleu de Chanel (5) - not sure why, but the incense in Bleu just explodes off my skin way too strong & I can't handle it
- Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) (10) - I so love this stuff!
- Cool Water (6) - great smell, but come off as overly synthetic now that I've smelled so many others & own GIT
- YSL L`Homme (7) - pretty nice scent
- YSL La Nuit de L`Homme (6) - sexy fragrance, just a tad too sweet & feminine on my skin
- Gucci Pour Homme II (9.5) - one of my favorites...beautifully blended & extremely versatile
- Ed Hardy Love & Luck (7) - a "nice" smell to me, but nothing special
- L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme (4) - this one just never quite "agreed" with my nose for some reason..don't really know why
- Tobacco Vanille (9.5) - as a fragrance, to me it's a wonderful masterpiece, but I don't find it very versatile at all
- New Haarlem (9) - another great blend, but like TV, I just don't find it that versatile
- Bleecker Street (6) - Improves in drydown, but the 1st 1-2 hrs are sharp, sour & very chemical on my skin
- Riverside Drive (8.5) - I really enjoy RD - one of the best bonds along with NH IMO
- Creed Silver Mountain Water (8) - I find it a beautiful fragrance...a bit feminine on my skin, though
- Creed Millesime Imperial (3) - sorry, but just don't get this one - all I got was chemical salt & light melon on my skin
- Creed Green Irish Tweed (10) - my absolute favorite fragrance of all - a masterful classic & my first true fragrance love
- Creed Aventus (10) - my 2nd favorite Creed & I love this stuff a little more each time I wear it. Soon to be a classic IMO

[The_Cologneist]

- A*Men (7)
- Le Male (7)
- Spicebomb (6)
- 1 Million (7)
- Givenchy Pi (7)
- Dior Fahrenheit (10)
- Dior Homme (vintage) (9)
- Burberry London (10)
- D&G The One (6)
- D&G Pour Homme (7)
- Armani Code (6)
- Acqua di Gio (7)
- Chanel Allure Homme (6)
- Chanel Allure Homme Sport (6)
- Bleu de Chanel (6)
- Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) (7)
- Cool Water (7)
- Versace Man Eau Fraiche (5)
- Versace Pour Homme (3)
- The Dreamer (8)
- YSL L`Homme (7)
- YSL La Nuit de L`Homme (10)
- Gucci Pour Homme II (7)
- Ed Hardy Love & Luck (4)
- L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme (3)
- Tobacco Vanille (8)
- New Haarlem (5)
- Wall Street (5)
- Creed Silver Mountain Water (8)
- Creed Green Irish Tweed (9)
- Creed Aventus (9)

[silentrich]

- Boucheron Jaipur Pour Homme (EDT) (7)
- Boucheron Pour Homme (EDT) (N/A)
- A*Men (8)
- CK One Shock (6)
- Le Male (7)
- Spicebomb (6)
- 1 Million (6)
- Givenchy Pi (7)
- Dior Fahrenheit (10)
- Dior Homme (vintage) (8)
- Burberry London (8)
- D&G The One (6)
- D&G Pour Homme (8)
- Armani Code (7)
- Acqua di Gio (7)
- Chanel Egoiste (9)
- Chanel Allure Homme (7)
- Chanel Allure Homme Sport (8)
- Bleu de Chanel (8)
- Abercrombie & Fitch Fierce (6)
- Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) (8)
- Cool Water (7)
- Versace Man Eau Fraiche (5)
- Versace Pour Homme (6)
- The Dreamer (7)
- YSL L`Homme (7)
- YSL La Nuit de L`Homme (5)
- Gucci Pour Homme II (9)
- Ed Hardy Love & Luck (7)
- L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme (8)
- Tobacco Vanille (8)
- New Haarlem (6)
- Chez Bond (5)
- Bleecker Street (9)
- Riverside Drive (7)
- Wall Street (6)
- Creed Silver Mountain Water (7)
- Creed Millesime Imperial (10)
- Creed Green Irish Tweed (10)
- Creed Aventus (10)

[Nihilist]

This is my collection. Please tell me what you think about each of them by giving them scores from 1-10.

In no particular order with my ratings:
- Boucheron Jaipur Pour Homme (EDT) (7)
- Boucheron Pour Homme (EDT) (8)
- A*Men (?)
- CK One Shock (?)
- Le Male (2)
- Spicebomb (9)
- 1 Million (?)
- Givenchy Pi (5)
- Dior Fahrenheit (?)
- Dior Homme (vintage) (?)
- Burberry London (7)
- D&G The One (8)
- D&G Pour Homme (5)
- Armani Code (4)
- Acqua di Gio (5)
- Chanel Egoiste (8)
- Chanel Allure Homme (?)
- Chanel Allure Homme Sport (?)
- Bleu de Chanel (?)
- Abercrombie & Fitch Fierce (?)
- Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) (8)
- Cool Water (6)
- Versace Man Eau Fraiche (?)
- Versace Pour Homme (?)
- The Dreamer (?)
- YSL L`Homme (?)
- YSL La Nuit de L`Homme (9)
- Gucci Pour Homme II (?)
- Ed Hardy Love & Luck (?)
- L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme (4)
- Tobacco Vanille (?)
- New Haarlem (?)
- Chez Bond (?)
- Bleecker Street (?)
- Riverside Drive (?)
- Wall Street (?)
- Creed Silver Mountain Water (?)
- Creed Millesime Imperial (?)
- Creed Green Irish Tweed (9)
- Creed Aventus (?)

inserted my ratings on those i have had time with. Boucheron PH a 2? wow i loved that stuff.

[CaliDude]

Nice collection!

My ratings:
- A*Men (7)
- Le Male (5)
- 1 Million (4)
- Burberry London (6)
- D&G Pour Homme (3)
- Armani Code (6)
- Acqua di Gio (6)
- Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) (8)
- Cool Water (3)
- Tobacco Vanille (8)
- New Haarlem (5)
- Chez Bond (1)
- Creed Silver Mountain Water (10)
- Creed Millesime Imperial (8)
- Creed Green Irish Tweed (10)
- Creed Aventus (8)

[SteelerOpera]

- A*Men 8.5
- CK One Shock 8
- Le Male 6.5
- Spicebomb 8
- 1 Million 7.5
- Givenchy Pi 8
- Dior Fahrenheit 9
- Dior Homme (vintage) 9
- D&G The One 7
- D&G Pour Homme 8
- Armani Code 6
- Acqua di Gio 7
- Chanel Egoiste 8.5 (Platinum - 7.5)
- Chanel Allure Homme 7
- Chanel Allure Homme Sport 6
- Bleu de Chanel 7.5
- Abercrombie & Fitch Fierce 7
- Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) 9.5
- Cool Water 8
- Versace Man Eau Fraiche 7.5
- Versace Pour Homme 7
- The Dreamer 8
- YSL L`Homme 7
- YSL La Nuit de L`Homme 8.5
- Gucci Pour Homme II 9
- Ed Hardy Love & Luck 7
- L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme 8.5
- Creed Millesime Imperial 9.5
- Creed Green Irish Tweed 9
- Creed Aventus 8

[MikeJ]

Only rating the ones I know
- A*Men (8)
- CK One Shock (7)
- Le Male (6)
- 1 Million (7)
- Givenchy Pi (5)
- Dior Fahrenheit (6)
- Burberry London (8)
- D&G The One (9)
- D&G Pour Homme (6)
- Armani Code (3)
- Acqua di Gio (7)
- Chanel Allure Homme (7)
- Chanel Allure Homme Sport (8)
- Bleu de Chanel (8)
- Abercrombie & Fitch Fierce (7)
- Cool Water (6)
- Versace Man Eau Fraiche (7)
- The Dreamer (4)
- YSL L`Homme (9)
- YSL La Nuit de L`Homme (8)
- Gucci Pour Homme II (8)
- Ed Hardy Love & Luck (7)
- L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme (4) -Summer 09 edition (8)/had to throw that one in
- Creed Millesime Imperial (7)

[RyanT]

Hall of Famers
- A*Men
- Le Male
- D&G Pour Homme
- The Dreamer
- L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme
- Tobacco Vanille
- Riverside Drive
- Creed Millesime Imperial
- Creed Green Irish Tweed

All-Stars
- Creed Aventus
- Dior Fahrenheit
- Dior Homme (vintage)
- Acqua di Gio
- Chanel Egoiste
- Abercrombie & Fitch Fierce
- Gucci Pour Homme II
- New Haarlem
- Chez Bond
- Bleecker Street

Starters
- Spicebomb
- 1 Million
- Burberry London
- Armani Code
- Chanel Allure Homme
- Chanel Allure Homme Sport
- Bleu de Chanel
- Cool Water
- Versace Man Eau Fraiche
- YSL La Nuit de L`Homme
- Wall Street
- Creed Silver Mountain Water

Part-Timers
- Boucheron Jaipur Pour Homme (EDT)
- CK One Shock
- Givenchy Pi
- D&G The One
- Versace Pour Homme
- YSL L`Homme

Bench Warmers
- Ed Hardy Love & Luck

[JyyskNotes]

some fragrances from your list:
- Le Male (4)
- Spicebomb (4)
- Dior Homme (vintage) (10)
- D&G The One (6)
- Chanel Allure Homme Sport (6)
- Bleu de Chanel (8)
- YSL L`Homme (9)
- Creed Silver Mountain Water (7)
- Creed Millesime Imperial (7)
- Creed Aventus (10)

[Possum-Pie]

- A*Men I LOVE IT, I HATE IT, I LOVE IT...
- Spicebomb YUCK
- 1 Million SMELLS LIKE A MILLION!
- Dior Fahrenheit SMELLS LIKE GASOLINE/PETROL
- Burberry London BRIT'S BETTER
- Acqua di Gio NICE BUT EVERYONE WEARS IT
Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) NICE
- Cool Water LESS EXPENSIVE ALTERNATIVE TO GIT.
- Versace Pour Homme EXCELLENT...TOP NOTCH
- YSL L`Homme I LIKE LIBRE MORE...
- Tobacco Vanille NICE FOR WINTER/FALL
- Bleecker Street CHEMICAL SMELLING
- Riverside Drive CHEMICAL SMELLING
- Wall Street SMELLS LIKE MOWED VINES
- Creed Silver Mountain Water GENERIC
- Creed Millesime Imperial GENERIC
- Creed Green Irish Tweed OVERUSED
- Creed Aventus OVERUSED

[sillage monster]

Omitting the ones I've never tried:

- A*Men (9.5)
- CK One Shock (8)
- Le Male (7.5)
- Spicebomb (7)
- 1 Million (6)
- Givenchy Pi (7)
- Dior Fahrenheit (9.5)
- Dior Homme (vintage) (10)
- Burberry London (8)
- D&G The One (4)
- Acqua di Gio (8)
- Abercrombie & Fitch Fierce (6)
- Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) (8)
- Cool Water (5)
- Versace Man Eau Fraiche (6)
- The Dreamer (9)
- YSL L`Homme (8)
- YSL La Nuit de L`Homme (6)
- Gucci Pour Homme II (10)
- Ed Hardy Love & Luck (7)
- L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme (6)
- Creed Silver Mountain Water (10)
- Creed Millesime Imperial (7)
- Creed Green Irish Tweed (10)
- Creed Aventus (9)

- - - Updated - - -

Omitting the ones I've never tried:

- A*Men (9.5)
- CK One Shock (8)
- Le Male (7.5)
- Spicebomb (7)
- 1 Million (6)
- Givenchy Pi (7)
- Dior Fahrenheit (9.5)
- Dior Homme (vintage) (10)
- Burberry London (8)
- D&G The One (4)
- Acqua di Gio (8)
- Abercrombie & Fitch Fierce (6)
- Terre D`Hermes (Parfum) (8)
- Cool Water (5)
- Versace Man Eau Fraiche (6)
- The Dreamer (9)
- YSL L`Homme (8)
- YSL La Nuit de L`Homme (6)
- Gucci Pour Homme II (10)
- Ed Hardy Love & Luck (7)
- L`eau D`Issey Pour Homme (6)
- Creed Silver Mountain Water (10)
- Creed Millesime Imperial (7)
- Creed Green Irish Tweed (10)
- Creed Aventus (9)