I disliked it, I'm afraid. I definitely get what you described as "jasmine mixed with mud", in my case I visualized clay... I think your question about whether it is too raw to wear is very apropos. I personally don't want to smell like Tawaf under any circumstances. All that said, I don't mean to imply it was terrible smelling or anything so harsh, but it is quite the challenging one, IMO (and not in a good way). The longevity issue you mention is also on point, but I guess I can give Tawaf a pass there due to it being all-natural.