I have not smelled Lynx Dark Temptation, so I do not know what would work. But it seems you tend to prefer fresher smelling things rather than darker ambery ones. My favorite fresh material is vetiver, which smells fresh, slightly green and grassy. Examples would be Tom Ford Grey Vetiver, Guerlain Vetiver, or Encre Noire. Another good fresh one would be YSL Rive Gauche for men.