"Gucci pour Homme I" (Tom Ford 2003), your opinion/quick poll

[Andrè Moreau]

Ok, The price is right and...it's the same : 40 euros (about 55 $)

I have to choose between a 100 ml AfterShave (black box) year 2008
OR
50 ml EDT year 2006 (white/black squares box)

mumble mumble.....
your opinion? (apart "buy both!") I can buy only one.

[StewartGallacher]

I'd take the eau de toilette.

[Mr. TL]

I'd take the eau de toilette.

easy decision.

[onethinline]

The EdT, easily.

[alfarom]

EDT, no doubt.

[nightcutter]

Eau de.

[Norstrøm]

Obviously the EdT

[dougczar]

EdT for sure

[Oviatt]

EdT and you won't regret it! Lovely stuff.

[L'Homme Blanc Individuel]

I'd take the eau de toilette.

Yup! This!

Gph is one of my favorite scents. It isn't one I get a lot of compliments on, but when I DO get a compliment on it, the compliment tends to be VERY enthusiastic!

[nfn1983]

EDT very easily!

[hednic]

I'd go with the 50 ml EDT year 2006 (white/black squares box)

[Zgb]

EDT without thinking!

[Nosebud]

thats a phenomenal price for EDT

[Oupavoc]

Easy EDT

[Andrè Moreau]

ok guys, EDT Vs. AftShave wins 20-0 ..... thank you.

I don't know international prices, however
here in Italy the 100ml EDT can be found in stores, but it's becoming difficult to find, at 60 euros (80 $),
EDT 50ml, and 100ml AfterShave, at 40 euros (55$),
EDT 30 ml ("traveller") at 35 euros.

[John E Buoy]

Yes, EDT.
And if you cannot find it again.....try Carbone de Balmain by Balmain, or Dirty English by Juicy Couture.

[senore01]

Edt
edt
edt
edt
edt

[El_Guapo]

Edt

[L'Homme Blanc Individuel]

here in Italy the 100ml EDT can be found in stores, but it's becoming difficult to find, at 60 euros (80 $)

THIS!!! I think it's definitely worth your effort to seek out a 100ml. Gph1 really is something special.

[staticx]

Go for the Edt. No second thoughts!!!
Then search for the 100 ml bottle :-)

[ericrico]

One must get the EdT first, but since the After Shave is also excellent (and rare)...definitely try to get both.

My SOTD - I had to say something. ;-)

Enjoy a modern masterpiece that is now discontinued...cheers.

ericrico

[Zgb]

Yes, EDT.
And if you cannot find it again.....try Carbone de Balmain by Balmain, or Dirty English by Juicy Couture.

or Man 2 by comme des garcons

[Shiny Beast]

Edt

[senore01]

EDT all the way my friend. But, if you can afford both, purchase both of these masterpieces. I adore GPH 1. Powerful, spicy, undeniably masculine.

[rbaker]

EdT

[KIG]

Edt

[Mr. TL]

or Man 2 by comme des garcons

Smells nothing like Gucci...

[The-odor]

I'd say be magnanimous... leave AfterShave there for those who couldn't get EDT.
And treasure your EDT, good price though!