Thought this would be a fun topic since there's some real hidden gems out there. My list so far is:

Michael Jordan Legend (New Haarlem on the cheap)

David Beckham Homme

Hillary Duff With Love (A feminine but completely unisex, gives a coconut/tropical feel)

McGraw Southern Blend (It's the best of the line, but considering how terrible the others are that's not saying much lol)

Sean John Unforgivable (Overpriced for what it is, but a decent MI clone)