First, let us ask this:
If not, moving on. The one scent that teen girls absolutely love is Abercrombie Fierce. It's the staple cologne for men in high school. I can't even begin to tell you how many compliments I got on that fragrance. Everyone loves it from young to old. It's a classic and in a way oozes class.
Mont Blanc Legend is one that came out recently and smells almost exactly like Fierce except it's toned down and a little less spicy, so if you don't appreciate scents that are overbearing or too powerful, then Legend is for you.
If you like sweet smelling fragrances: Rochas Man, Body Kouros, and Legend by Michael Jordan are all superb fragrances that girls love.
Overall, I'd say girls at that age like something sweet or spicy with a hint of freshness.
However, I a confident teen can also sport Dior Homme Intense, Versace Dreamer and Burberry London.
It's all a matter of taste and how you wear it. Bvlgari Black and Midnight in Paris would be a risk as you could get teased for smelling a little too feminine but the leather/rubber note would appeal that viewpoint.
Davidoff Cool Water and Joop by Joop are two other classics where you can't really go wrong at that age.
I'm buying a fragrance for my cousin who's a senior in high school and I will be choosing one of these from the above listed