I'm still partial to the vanillas by B&BW. If you love vanilla, Body Fantasies vanilla (drug store) is pretty good too, but it's very sweet.
I've found that I have some vanilla from B&BW that's a few years old, it's a cream and it has shimmer in it (the shimmer is why I rarely wear it). I layered it under a perfume for a party, and it was LOVELY!!!