Hello to all, a recent thread discussing mint-herbal scents revived my interest in this style. I feel it has a lot of potential if done well.
I'ved tried Creed's Selection Verte, and like it a lot. Lovely orange blossom with mint and herbs. Wears very well.
I've also tried MPG's Centaur. While that is a minty scent, to me it seems primarily a mossy scent. I find it a dark sort of scent (verging on powerhouse) which is brightened and balanced by mint.
I have not had the opportunity to try L'Artisan Parfumeur's L'Eau du Caporal. Some discussion compares it to Centaur, I wonder if any agree about that.