I would have to be sold to buy that.
Atleast parts of me.
Thread: Amouage Beloved Man
Discover my Guest Reviewer Of The Day here
I would have to be sold to buy that.
Atleast parts of me.
lol Johnny. The price is definitely steep. It almost scares me that the thought of spending say, $150 on a scent nowadays seems "cheap". I remember the day, about 6 or 7 years ago, when I lambasted a coworker for spending like $60 on a bottle of D&G By Man (which was not discontinued then, and of which I had no idea of what it was like). I just kept saying "do you know what ELSE you could have bought with $60? Cologne? Seriously?!"
I remember when I thought $30 for a fragrance was outrageous.
Last edited by noggs; 30th January 2013 at 11:26 AM.
oh wow, there goes my lunch money.
Nice preliminary review SoS; it sounds delightful and promising. I will test it and first chance I get.
Is the juice worth the squeeze?
Split already on with KRON!
The opening is just incredible. The grapefruit and elemi are noticeable but thanks to the already prominent orris and leather/suede note, they are incredibly round; the rendering of these notes is unlike anything I can think of at the moment. They only have the complete spotlight for a minute or two, but it is a grand introduction. A friend/fellow DIY perfumer once sent me the most incredible iris absolute; this was the stuff of legend. It had the clarity of Dior Homme's iris, the sweetness of the iris in Guerlinade, and some of the body and rootiness of the iris found in Iris Bleu Gris. Along with being ethereal and slightly powdery, it had a soft but noticeable raspberry note to it. The iris I smell in Beloved Man is the closest I've ever smelled to that legendary sample I had. And yes, there is a hint of raspberry in the first hour or so of Beloved Man. It's deftly integrated though, standing out far less than similar notes in other scents, and I believe most will probably not think 'oh yeah, raspberry!' unless they are looking for it, namely because it's an airy, almost transparent rendition of the note. Later on, the fruity aspects of jasmine absolute combine with some other notes and continue a red fruit impression. I'll elaborate more on that in the future as I'm still trying to figure out exactly what the note is/where it's coming from.
Regarding the opening, It's interesting how it is only after the brief but luminescent opening of yellow and gold that the orange note moves to the fore. As I said before, it then moves into an orange/orris/leather phase, and the peridot green base slowly makes itself more known as time goes on. I get hints of tobacco (I think this is the saffron note at work), a bit of jasmine green tea, dried grass. This sits under the lightly powdered leather/orange/orris accord, and the juxtaposition of the two calls to mind Nasomatto's China White (and in some ways, probably thanks to the grapefruit/green combination, Invasion Barbare). There is even some overlap with China White in basic scent profile, but (and I just compared them both on paper earlier today to make sure) Beloved feels much more natural, round, and lively. If you ever wanted to describe to a non-scent oriented person what three dimensionality in a fragrance smells like, Beloved is the scent you'd want to show them.
If anything, Trebor, it's really unlike any other Amouage scent. It's got a bit of Caron DNA, and definitely some Guerlain DNA. Some Dior, perhaps, too? It's definitely a classical men's scent done in a modern way. The late base does have a faint resemblance to Tribute attar (not too surprising I suppose when you look at the note overlap) but it's much softer. Smoother. The whole scent is smooth. Very smooth. They did a good job of capturing the romantic element, while managing to avoid making it overtly sexy. In that sense, it's character is something like a cross between Dior Homme (confident, slightly feminine, romantic and sexy) and Invasion Barbare (confident, masculine, not overtly sexy but almost seems to condense masculinity as a whole down into a fragrance, much the way Old Spice and Brut do).
So Trebor, I don't know that you'll like it, but I have no doubt that you will find it quite different than anything else by the house. I think you and I could both ID a new Amouage scent as being from Amouage if it continued along the trajectory of the mainline. I don't think most would immediately think Amouage if smelling Beloved blindly. I'm guessing many would think it's a new Guerlain from one of their exclusive lines.
Thanks for this review SculptureOfSoul, it's amazing how you can "reverse engineer" fragrances and be able to identify the different notes, sometimes I find it very hard to do that!
Thanksalot for your impressions, sculpture
1) It's not easy, and it takes a lot of work in the best of cases. I can usually pick up major notes and things with a few regular wearings, but for a detailed breakdown (which I only occasionally do, when I find the composition novel or the scent particularly moving) takes numerous wears and detailed scrutiny. I have been known to sit around for a couple of hours doing nothing but smelling the scent, jotting down notes, etc. Odd? Probably. But I find it enjoyable - it's like listening to an album or watching a movie I love.
2) I've worked with natural perfumery materials (about 200 or so) for a number of years now, and that really helped me to learn not only how various notes smell, but how they can be utilized. Some notes 'lift' other notes. Some notes may just add a depth or roundness. Some notes round other notes. You get the idea. Anyhow, I will say that despite all I've learned I know there is still SO much more to learn, and in so many ways I'm still just a beginner. I have very little experience with synthetic aroma chemicals, which is something I'd like to rectify in the next year or two.
3) This ties into the last part of point 2. Given that I don't have experience with many synthetics, and most scents (yes, even high end niche) are predominantly synthetic, I give my impressions based on what notes these synthetics mimic, and how my nose perceives them. I suppose I would probably still do that even if I did know the synthetics, as I don't know how helpful it would be to say "and then the phenyethyl acetate note comes to the fore, flanked by some methyl anthranilate and aurantiol." Well, I suppose if the synthetics were described in more detail, such reviews might be interesting to a select few. We'll see, I may end up incorporating that kind of analysis into future reviews if/when I get the necessary knowledge to do so. Anyhow, as it is now, I explain the notes my nose perceives, and also the way those notes seem to interact with each other (their structural, compositional function) based on my own experience with naturals. I may be way off the mark with my analysis at times, but my goal is not to reduce the scent down to a formula anyhow. My goal is to shine some light on the beauty of the architectural side of a perfume, as I think there is just as much beauty and intrigue in the workings of the composition (and from that, trying to guess what the perfumer was thinking) as there are in the final smell itself. If anyone reads one of my detailed breakdowns and finds something new to love about a scent they already enjoy, then I have succeeded.
While we tend to have very different tastes, SoS, the way you write and describe your experience with the scents you enjoy always makes it mandatory for me to try every one of them. You have a real way with words for sure! You make a strong case for Beloved Man here, even though I personally am not the biggest fan of either Dior Homme or Invasion Barbare...
Current Top Favorites:
1) Portrait of a Lady original formula (EdP Frédéric Malle)
2) Giorgio for Men vintage/V.I.P. for Men (Giorgio Beverly Hills)
3) Dia Man vintage edt (Amouage)
4) Anat Fritz Original Formula and Classical (Anat Fritz) - tie
4) Lalfeorosa (O'driù) - tie
6) Les Nombres d'Or Vetyver (Mona di Orio)
7) Captain vintage (Molyneux)
8) Tzora (Anat Fritz)
9) Javanese Patchouli (Zegna) - tie
9) Monsieur de Givenchy vintage (Givenchy) - tie
9) Coeur de Vetiver Sacré (L'Artisan) - tie
9) Polo vintage (Ralph Lauren) - tie
9) Patou pour Homme Privé (Jean Patou) - tie
9) Oud Shamash (The Different Company) - tie
As I said it's really not like either one of them, individually, so I think there's a chance you might like it. I'm curious to see if anyone is going to find some of the scents embellishments to be 'too modern.' I tend to like modern scents more than classical scents (such as K10, or another I went back and resniffed to compare recently, Dunhill '34). I think both K10 and Dunhill are masterpieces and absolutely top notch compositions, but they're just not 'me.' Beloved, being a modern take on classical notes, is much more to my liking. I really don't own any classical scents (outside of maybe Grey Flannel, if you'd call it that), but I can definitely see myself owning a bottle of Beloved, some day.
Ah, I can't believe I forgot to mention that I'm actually not that big a fan of Dior Homme, Invasion Barbare or China White. I like the basic idea behind them, but there's something in each of them that just doesn't work for me.
I can't wait to try this one. I wonder what the easiest way to sample it would be since it's going to be exclusive to Bergdorf in the US. Would they send me a sample if I called and asked?
I tried this earlier today morning, and found it to quite similar to the drydown of opus vi, but longevity and or sillage is somewhat poorer than opus vi (which is monstrous) also i believe Beloved MAN is nearer to Interlude man than anything else in the amouage line, so far - i am already not favoring it, it isnt bad, its got the lovely orris root that i like but besides that its got that "wannabe" vibe that Interlude has, and lacks that effortless elegance of Opus VI and or Epic Man, my two favorites from this house, i also tried Tribute Attar today, and as fantastic as it was - it will be impossible to wear in my climate - i was also told that Opus 7 will be releasing somewhere in June!
Last edited by benzganesh; 10th February 2013 at 08:09 PM.
Not close to Interlude please.
Heart of Interlude means a bitter smokey heart?
smokey vetiverish, somewhat "yesteryear" perfume accord, also quite similar to Dia, but the vetiver has that strong interlude link, was quite dissapointed, but happy i don't have to think much about it now!
I also heard a rumour that Opus VII may be the final Opus entry. Personally, I hope not but, if it is, I really hope that they pull out the stops for this one.
Current Favorites (not in any particular order)
Hanae Mori HM EDT