How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

**el_payo** · 27th January 2013, 12:03 PM

the dreamer and bvlgari extreme

**Johnny_Ludlow** · 27th January 2013, 12:51 PM

Mouchoir de Monsieur is the only one I can give 10/10 to without any hesitation.

**Dailey** · 27th January 2013, 02:58 PM

Turned out to be a great thread - thanks for all the input. I have a massive cut and paste into word that I will be using as a test list for loads of these :-)

**Duke Hunt** · 28th January 2013, 03:50 PM

Absolue pour le soir
Xerjoff Homme
Invasion Barbare
Memoir Man
L'air du desert Marocain
Derby
Kouros
Jicky
Knize Ten
Puredistance M
Bois Des Iles
Dior Homme
1740
31 Rue Cambon
Green Irish Tweed
Egoiste
Muscs Koublai Khan
Sycomore

**forfreddie** · 28th January 2013, 03:59 PM

I also have a lot of 9's and 8's and nothing below a 7 - I love well-thought out collections

I never rate fragrances though so I've just been really really strict.

10/10 fragrances:

Haute Claire by Aftelier Perfumes
Secret Garden by Aftelier Perfumes
Eau De Parfum 2011 by Comme Des Garcons
Rubj EDP by Vero.Profumo
Bosque by Humiecki and Graef
Miel De Bois by Serge Lutens
Musc Maori by Parfumerie Generale
Miriam by Tableau De Parfums

<3

**staticx** · 28th January 2013, 04:02 PM

These come to my mind first:

Fahrenheit
Gucci pH I/II
Bang
Narciso Rodriguez for Him
Taste of Fragrance
Paul Smith Man
MiP EDP
Terre D Hermes
M7
Artisan
London Burberry
Eau De Bavx etc

**timmy-j** · 28th January 2013, 05:28 PM

Considering it's 10 out of 10, and not just my "favorites" I would have to say none really. I have smelled a lot that I really like and think very highly of but nothing that is perfect or that I would consider to be my holy grail. But to be fair I have only sampled 1/100th of what most of you have.

**engar** · 28th January 2013, 05:35 PM

Sycomore and JXXV

**döfä91** · 28th January 2013, 10:58 PM

None. But some of the 5-star fragrances in my wardrobe i would rate 9.

**Le Grand Duc** · 29th January 2013, 12:35 AM

Originally Posted by andregooren

Out of my collection of right around 100:

Azurée Estée Lauder (eau de toilette)
Bandit Robert Piguet (eau de parfum)
Bel Ami Hermès (eau de toilette)
Black Bulgari (eau de toilette)
Cuir d'Iris Parfumerie Generale (parfum extrait)
Cuir de Russie Chanel (eau de toilette)
Cuir de Russie Chanel (parfum extrait)
Cuir de Russie Chanel (vintage eau de cologne)
Cuir Fétiche Maître Parfumeur et Gantier (eau de parfum)
Cuir Ottoman Parfum d'Empire (eau de parfum)
Cuir Mauresque Serge Lutens (eau de parfum)
Dior Homme Dior (eau de toilette)
Dzing! L'Artisan Parfumeur (eau de toilette)
Dzongkha L'Artisan Parfumeur (eau de toilette)
Égoïste Chanel (eau de toilette)
Fracas Robert Piguet (vintage parfum extrait)
Habit Rouge Guerlain (eau de toilette)
Knize Ten Knize (eau de toilette)
Mitsouko Guerlain (eau de parfum)
Monsieur Rochas Rochas (vintage eau de toilette concentrée)
Oud Cuir d'Arabie Montale (eau de parfum)
Patchouli 24 Le Labo (eau de parfum)
Royal English Leather Creed (eau de toilette)
Sarrasins Serge Lutens (eau de parfum)
Shalimar Guerlain (eau de toilette)
Shalimar Guerlain (parfum extrait)
Tabac Blond Caron (parfum extrait)
Vol de Nuit Guerlain (eau de toilette)
Yatagan Caron (eau de toilette)

This post is a treat for the eyes ...

**Dailey** · 30th January 2013, 09:05 PM

Originally Posted by forfreddie

I also have a lot of 9's and 8's and nothing below a 7 - I love well-thought out collections

I never rate fragrances though so I've just been really really strict.

10/10 fragrances:

Haute Claire by Aftelier Perfumes
Secret Garden by Aftelier Perfumes
Eau De Parfum 2011 by Comme Des Garcons
Rubj EDP by Vero.Profumo
Bosque by Humiecki and Graef
Miel De Bois by Serge Lutens
Musc Maori by Parfumerie Generale
Miriam by Tableau De Parfums

<3

Hey Freddie, been watching some of your videos, great stuff! Do you have a main source for some of these more obscure frags (lots u mention I have never seen)

**Awésome** · 31st January 2013, 01:36 AM

Dhi
Lidge
Scent intense
Pure malt

**eMCizzle** · 31st January 2013, 04:31 AM

Aventus (Creed)
Lumiere Noire Pour Homme (Maison Francis Kurkdjian)

**portugal** · 31st January 2013, 07:34 AM

EGOiSTE
TERRE HERMES
ALLURE
RIVE GAUCHE

**hadrian** · 31st January 2013, 01:23 PM

For me, a 10/10 perfume combines my pleasure, as a wearer, and the importance of the frag in the recent history of that beautiful vice that we share.
So:
Givenchy Gentlemen
Azzaro PH
Aramis
Davidoff Cool Water
Paco Rabanne PH
Terre d.Hermes
Dior Eau Sauvage
Armani Eau PH

**LucasKane** · 31st January 2013, 07:14 PM

Vetiver Extraordinaire
Patchouli 24
Sequoia
Kyoto
Decalaration

Today that is...

**LucasKane** · 31st January 2013, 07:15 PM

Vetiver Extraordinaire
Patchouli 24
Sequoia
Kyoto
Decalaration

Today that is...

**Oscroft** · 31st January 2013, 11:23 PM

10/10? Tricky. And my choice would be probably be different if you asked me again in a few months. But here's a first pass...

Chanel Égoïste
Czech & Speake No. 88
Creed Original Vetiver
Dior Eau Sauvage
Dior Eau Sauvage Parfum
Guerlain Jicky EdP
Guerlain Vetiver
Penhaligon's Sartorial
YSL Rive Gauche

**SevereWX** · 1st February 2013, 09:41 PM

From my small, humble collection, I'd rate the following 10/10: Egoiste by Chanel, Red for Men by Giorgio Beverly Hills, Prada Amber pour Homme Intense, and though many might heartily laugh and vehemently disagree: Stetson by Coty.

**comfortablynumbbg** · 2nd February 2013, 12:32 AM

3.

DioR Homme Intense
Tobacco Vanille
Aventus

**pokpok** · 2nd February 2013, 05:46 AM

Chanel Coromandel
Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille

I can wear these 2 for the rest of my life and not get sick of it. 10/10

**Azieru** · 2nd February 2013, 08:51 AM

A lot of my favorites are close 10's, Aventus is my most versatile fragrance so its a 10+

**craniumbash** · 2nd February 2013, 10:37 AM

I recently started so I'd say DHI vintage, YSL La Nuit, M7 vintage, and spice bomb (just almost everyone adores it on me) also I got my hands on oud oil and its really good IMO (though burberry london was a 10 for me not so long ago). Going to get my hands on Aventus and Dior Dune in the future Inshahallah so that may count too

**Slayerized** · 2nd February 2013, 11:26 AM

- Loewe Esencia: Sheer green perfection in a bottle
- MPG: Santal Noble: A sandalwood smell that is very hard to dislike; very well blended sophisticated juice
- Paco Rabanne pour homme (real vintage): Just smell it and you'll know. It's nothing like latest versions

**ustad** · 2nd February 2013, 12:16 PM

Aventus
Noir de Noir
Timbuktu
Tea for Two
Musc Ravageur

**morrison74** · 2nd February 2013, 01:50 PM

Everything in my very small wardrobe:

Ungaro II
Fahrenheit (vintage)
D&G Pour Homme (vintage)
Dunhill Edition (vintage)
Rive Gauche pour Homme (tin can)
Casual Friday
Amber Absolute
Yohji homme
IUNX L'Ether
Tobacco Vanille

**irrbloss** · 4th February 2013, 09:28 PM

Invasion Barbare - always a 10
Clive Christian No 1 Men - always a 10
Michael for Men (the original formulation) - 10 (actually a little lower, but for the price it's a perfect 10)
Creed Aventus - sometimes a 10, but most of the time a 9

**Fahrenheit** · 5th February 2013, 12:56 AM

Fahrenheit 10/10

**iivanita** · 13th February 2013, 10:00 AM

1. La Myrrhe (own only 10 ml)
2. Shalimar (vint)
3. 31 Rue Cambon
4. Homage
5. Vanilia
6. Ubar (2009) dont own it

(
7.Sacrebleu

10/10 means i would repurchase them again

**forfreddie** · 13th February 2013, 10:09 AM

Hi Daley, sorry I didn't see you reply!
Sending you a PM

Thread: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Thread Tools

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Re: How many in your collection do you rate 10 out of 10 and which?

Similar Threads

Rate my collection please!

Rate my collection too , please

Please rate my collection....

Please rate my collection

Please Help, rate my collection.. :)

Posting Permissions