Code of Conduct
Results 1 to 9 of 9
  1. #1

    Default Are these different enough to warrant buying?

    I'm currently looking to buy a new fragrance but the ones that I find interesting seem to have some redundancy... Can you guys elaborate on the differences between the respective fragrances and give your opinion if its worth buying these fragrances if I already have the following fragrances?

    Have: D&G The One
    Have: Paco Rabanne PH
    Have: La Nuit L'Homme

    Interested In: Terre D'Hermes
    Interested In: Rive Gauche
    Interested In: La Nuit L'Homme le Parfum

  2. #2
    hednic's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    McLean, NYC, & Búzios
    Posts
    84,205

    Default Re: Are these different enough to warrant buying?

    The three you're interested in are all worth buying IMO.

  3. #3

    Default Re: Are these different enough to warrant buying?

    Actually I have/had the later group and would never buy any of the former
    Those three are pretty unique, and La Nuit LP has barely no resemblance with the original.
    We want a 'Niche' forum.

  4. #4

    Default Re: Are these different enough to warrant buying?

    I’ve not tried La Nuit Parfum, so I’ll only comment on the first two pairings:

    1) The One vs Td’H*.

    Extremely different.

    The One is a soft, warm, powdery and sweet/spicy fragrance with god-awful projection and sub-par longevity. I really like the scent of it, but long for a stronger version. It’s a fantastic evening scent, because it becomes a skin scent after 2 hours or so.

    The Td’H is a cooler scent – the green citrus opening is often described as ‘sharp’ or ‘metallic’ – but soon the citrus opening softens (but pleasingly, and in contrast to many citrus frags, stays around for the life of the scent) and allows the vetiver to play a more prominent role.
    The projection and longevity on this (and the Parfum) is excellent. I get 12 hours and over from either version.

    Despite its strength, Td’H is a terrific work fragrance – provided it’s applied sparingly. The One is a much better evening fragrance, and is a proven compliment getter from women, who seem to like the soft sweetness of the drydown.

    I think you’d be doing yourself a disservice if you didn’t have Td’H. I’d suggest sniffing out both the EDT and the Parfum. I prefer the Parfum, but am happy I have both in my wardrobe.

    *presumably you mean the EDT, but some of my comments also apply to the Parfum, which is a much warmer, smoother and woodier Td’H.

    2) Rabanne PH* vs RG

    Again, almost no similarities, save for the fact that they’re often both referred to as ‘barbershop’ fragrances.
    This is because PR has a classic ‘masculine’ scent associated with the image of the clean-cut man of the 1950s, and RG allegedly smells like Barbasol shaving cream (I’ve never smelled Barbasol so I can’t comment).

    They smell exactly nothing alike to my nose – RG is a very clean, spicy, soapy fragrance that’s often compared to Azzaro PH. I also feel it’s in a similar vein to the Taylor of Old Bond Street colognes. I’m not saying it smells like any one TOBS scent, but rather it has the same understated, soapy appeal that those British colognes have.

    PR, on the other hand, is more akin (but certainly not entirely similar) to Antaeus, Kouros et al. It has an unapologetically brash opening and I feel it even smells acrid, in stark contrast to the smooth, mature RG. PR still smells quite clean on the drydown, but not in the same soapy way that RG does.

    The only other similarities between the two are their above-average projection and longevity. I hear the occasional person say RG has poor longevity, but I easily get 6+ hours from it, and I feel it outdoes PR in that regard.

    I bought PR because it was a good price and won’t buy it again, whereas I’ve got two backup bottles of RG. It’s clear where my preference lies.

    *I have the current formulation, so can’t comment on vintage PR PH.

  5. #5

    Default Re: Are these different enough to warrant buying?

    I agree!
    Quote Originally Posted by hednic View Post
    The three you're interested in are all worth buying IMO.

  6. #6

    Default Re: Are these different enough to warrant buying?

    Quote Originally Posted by timdoeswell View Post
    I’ve not tried La Nuit Parfum, so I’ll only comment on the first two pairings:

    1) The One vs Td’H*.

    Extremely different.

    The One is a soft, warm, powdery and sweet/spicy fragrance with god-awful projection and sub-par longevity. I really like the scent of it, but long for a stronger version. It’s a fantastic evening scent, because it becomes a skin scent after 2 hours or so.

    The Td’H is a cooler scent – the green citrus opening is often described as ‘sharp’ or ‘metallic’ – but soon the citrus opening softens (but pleasingly, and in contrast to many citrus frags, stays around for the life of the scent) and allows the vetiver to play a more prominent role.
    The projection and longevity on this (and the Parfum) is excellent. I get 12 hours and over from either version.

    Despite its strength, Td’H is a terrific work fragrance – provided it’s applied sparingly. The One is a much better evening fragrance, and is a proven compliment getter from women, who seem to like the soft sweetness of the drydown.

    I think you’d be doing yourself a disservice if you didn’t have Td’H. I’d suggest sniffing out both the EDT and the Parfum. I prefer the Parfum, but am happy I have both in my wardrobe.

    *presumably you mean the EDT, but some of my comments also apply to the Parfum, which is a much warmer, smoother and woodier Td’H.

    2) Rabanne PH* vs RG

    Again, almost no similarities, save for the fact that they’re often both referred to as ‘barbershop’ fragrances.
    This is because PR has a classic ‘masculine’ scent associated with the image of the clean-cut man of the 1950s, and RG allegedly smells like Barbasol shaving cream (I’ve never smelled Barbasol so I can’t comment).

    They smell exactly nothing alike to my nose – RG is a very clean, spicy, soapy fragrance that’s often compared to Azzaro PH. I also feel it’s in a similar vein to the Taylor of Old Bond Street colognes. I’m not saying it smells like any one TOBS scent, but rather it has the same understated, soapy appeal that those British colognes have.

    PR, on the other hand, is more akin (but certainly not entirely similar) to Antaeus, Kouros et al. It has an unapologetically brash opening and I feel it even smells acrid, in stark contrast to the smooth, mature RG. PR still smells quite clean on the drydown, but not in the same soapy way that RG does.

    The only other similarities between the two are their above-average projection and longevity. I hear the occasional person say RG has poor longevity, but I easily get 6+ hours from it, and I feel it outdoes PR in that regard.

    I bought PR because it was a good price and won’t buy it again, whereas I’ve got two backup bottles of RG. It’s clear where my preference lies.

    *I have the current formulation, so can’t comment on vintage PR PH.

    Amazing breakdown, thank you for all the details! I live in socal and the weather is starting to warm up again considerably while the nights are still a bit cooler. You've convinced me that Terre D'Hermes will be my next buy for the coming spring!

    Can anyone elaborate more on La nuit vs La Nuit le Parfum though?

  7. #7

    Default Re: Are these different enough to warrant buying?

    Terre D'Hermes is very different than any of the 5 you listed. It's great if you like it.

  8. #8

    Default Re: Are these different enough to warrant buying?

    The ones you are interested in are very different from the ones you already have, but of the ones you are interested in, Terre d'Hermes is the only one worth owning IMO.

  9. #9

    Default Re: Are these different enough to warrant buying?

    how about Terre d'Hermes vs Monsieur de Givenchy, can anyone comment on the differences between these two? Is TdH considerably more modern than MdG?

Similar Threads

  1. What are you buying next ?
    By Nersh in forum Male Fragrance Discussion
    Replies: 93
    Last Post: 2nd June 2014, 03:13 PM
  2. Buying MI
    By noirdrakkar in forum Just Starting Out
    Replies: 9
    Last Post: 27th June 2012, 11:06 PM
  3. Im almost buying...
    By d4N13L in forum Female Fragrance Discussion
    Replies: 8
    Last Post: 7th December 2011, 06:42 AM
  4. I like it, but I'm not buying it anyway!
    By Cognoscento in forum Just Starting Out
    Replies: 9
    Last Post: 29th June 2006, 08:51 PM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  



Loving perfume on the Internet since 2000