Guerlain have done a pretty decent job with Mitsouko.
Thread: Best Reformulations? |
Looks like we're looking for lists today. Since the vast majority of reformulated classics seem to get "butchered" in the review section, I am curious if there are any that would be considered a success. I personally haven't a clue. What say you?![]()
Guerlain have done a pretty decent job with Mitsouko.
Fine fragrance is alive; it breathes, unfolds and unravels with each passing hour....
Roja Dove
Apparently the new version of Sova is much better than "Tunis Mills" as it was once called. Josh is certainly happy with it.
Dior Homme Intense is ridiculously wicked. Actually prefer it to the original overall.
Fahrenheit
Givenchy Gentleman
I find the terms "best" and "reformulations" mutually exclusive.
Last edited by Partario; 2nd February 2013 at 12:03 AM.
A worthy reformulation for me is Gengis Khan.
They did a supremely good job with Giorgio for Men.
Dior Homme Sport 2013 can certainly hold its own against the 2008 version.
First of all, we only know of a small number of "official"' reformulations, so this is all guesswork on our part. When an expensive designer scent goes "drug store," it's basically silly to say it must be the same formulation. That's not the way the industry works. Red for Men by GBH, for example, supposedly had about 550 ingredients and around 35 naturals, and it smells like it. Does anyone believe that the reformulation is the same? Sure, they tried to do a good job, but so do a lot of other "cheapos" companies (such as Perfumer's Workshop). In the case of Boss #1 (which used to be Boss Cologne), I haven't detected differences that I would describe as major, but then again this one is not a "drug store" scent (unless that happened recently and I didn't notice). Niche reformulations can be just about anything, but now they must follow the new guidelines, so if you liked a niche scent with a lot of oakmoss, don't expect it to smell the same. I suggest getting some samples of new and vintage and studying them over time. Eventually you'll notice differences and you can decide for yourself if it is important to you.
Visit my huge swap page: http://www.basenotes.net/threads/211...-ml-Gotham-etc
Or visit my Sales page: http://www.basenotes.net/threads/211...o-make-offers!
Samples, etc. for Sale at my Crystal Flacon page: http://flacon.ambaric.net/viewtopic.php?t=282
My fragrance blog: http://bigslyfragrance.wordpress.com/