Honestly I find this extremely pretentious. Not everyone is a veteran in the fragrance game, and most people just want their questions answered. If I am new to a fragrance, like I am with vintage DHI, I am going to want to talk about it and start threads. If you don't like it, don't post. Simple as that.
As for the multiple threads on the same fragrance thing, I can get that. However, this is the internet, and things like this are going to happen, just like they do on every other website ever in the history of the world. You just have to accept that not everyone is willing to search and respond to one thread.
Not to mention, a lot of people want tailored responses to their questions, and on basenotes, there is no alert function for when you are quoted...which is really behind the curve if I am honest. Without this, people are more inclined, myself included, to make new threads.