I have owned only two bottles of this scent, as I pretty much like it. I didn't enjoy it as much initially, but with more wearings it started to grow on me. It's just a tad too sweet for me. Only thing I noticed with both bottles that I purchased is that I get a cake batter scent going on from my current bottle and my first bottle of this. Both bottles smell identical on me. Sometimes testers can be older if they have been around for awhile, so that could be a possibility. Which scent of this do you prefer the sweet powdery scent or the coffee and brown sugar one?