All of it is top notch for the price.
The pre/post cream is the best pre-shave I've ever used, and when combined with the green shaving cream and the aftershave splash, gives you a face-freezing menthol blast that's up there with Osage Rub. The green line is perfect for warmer weather.
I really like the new red-label sandalwood and shea butter shaving cream; the scent is true-to-life and, like the rest of the proraso creams, lathers up like a rabid dog.
I've got a couple of bottles of the blue label (aloe and vitamin E) aftershave balm, and I'm not sold on it. It moisturises perfectly well, but the scent isn't great.
In so far as their soaps are concerned (which are softer soaps) they're fine, but I'd take tubes of the creams (green and red) over them.
Proraso is an excellent Italian barbershop line that outperforms products several times more expensive.
Jump on the Proraso train, Ken, you'll see why every wetshaver has some Proraso in their collection.