Rose 31 or Black Aoud for me
I must concur with Hammam Bouquet. A spicy, powdery Victorian rose of great depth. I must also suggest Washington Tremlett Black Tie.
Something else: Ungaro II
Montale Black Aoud is the rose for me so far, though I'm coming around to Rose 31 (I see it in the same category as Cartier Declaration -- woody, spicy, transparent). I like Noir de Noir before it gets to the end, when I just get cheap (think Nestlé Quik) cocoa powder.