So, I've tried probably a dozen Jo Malones, and own a couple of 1oz bottles.
I feel many of the typical comments ring true with regard to them, I think; they're soft, natural smelling, arguably over-priced, fairly short-lived, clean and pleasant.
Words I wouldn't use to describe them, however, include challenging and complex, unless you refer to the challenge of having to smell like a chocolate orange from wearing their new Sugar and Spice range.
I bought Black Vetyver Cafe because it was so damned nice, and I thought it was as close to complex as the range got.
Pomegranate Noir came along and opened my eyes. It is the one Malone frag that I can't say for certainty whether I like it or not. It wavers between smoky/dry and juicy/semi-sweet. I mean there's fruit, spice, wood, musk, florals and a whole bunch more in there. I've tried it twice and can't get a good read on it.
I'd love to hear from you guys about any experiences with Jo Malone fragrances that you find complex, or even just the Malones you find to be standouts amongst the range. PN has definitely thrown me for a loop.
Joe Malone Lime And Basil...Hated it. If I found it good I would say why lol
Rose Water & Vanilla has great longevity and projection. In that way it's a stand out.
Tom Ford Private Blend Splits Costa Azzurra / Mandarino Di Amalfi / Oud Wood / Tobacco Vanille / Tobacco Oud / Neroli Portofino / Noir de Noir / Tuscan Leather / Plum Japonais/ Oud Fleur / Italian Cypress / Venetian Bergamot / Jasmin Rouge / Café Rose / Amber Absolute HERE
Pomegranate Noir is the only one I have purchased. Worthy. But I bought it at Christmas in a box with some name like Library collection... It had the bottle od PN and three 10ml bottles of monochords to layer with it. One of them was Gaiac. Holy cow! The best gaiac I have smelled so far but damn, only 10ml. I wrote to them and told them it ahould be released anf begged for more. Never heard back.
Jo Malone is incredible. So sad the scents are so weak. They should make a line of parfums or extraits. That would cut into their profit margins though so I suspect it will never happen. So therefore I will not be buying more.
Most worn scents according to my haphazard use of the SOTD...so perhaps my favorites...
1. Epic Man by Amouage (21 wears)
2. M7 by Eves Saint Laurent (18 wears)
3. Leather Oud by Christian Dior (18 wears)
4. Oud Imperial (black) by Perris Monte Carlo (14 wears)
5. Russian Tea Ritual by Masque (12 wears)
6. Fate Man by Amouage (11 wears)
7. Terre d'Hermes by Hermes (11 wears plus - often not recorded go to scent)
8. Interlude Man by Amouage (11 wears)
9. Journey Man by Amouage (11 wears)
10. Plum Japonais by Tom Ford, Bullion by Byredo, Piper Nigrum by a Lorenzo Villorosi, Pulp by Byredo, Santal Royal by Guerlain (9 wears)
Be who you are and say what you feel, because those who mind don't matter and those who matter don't mind.
Pom Noir is my fav from the line, it seems to have fairly good longevity too. I also like Amber & Lavendar and Blue Agave & Cacao.
Was given a large sample of 154 by a sales associate last year. Didn't care for it really at all. I keep coming back to it, but it has a sour pseudo-leather-ish note that just comes off as a dirty smell to me.
Other Jo Malones I have tried have been pleasant, but not "wow".
There are some lovely scents in the Malone line, and if they even lasted a good 4 hours they'd be worth a purchase. At $90 an oz here in Australia, I find it hard to justify the pricetag if I only get a couple of hours from them.
They would be good decanted into a travel sprayer and kept in the briefcase, though.
The only one I would call complex is amber lavender and it last longer than the others. The one that has numbers " I think 154" is not bad but not great either. The others are too sweet for me.
I have Blue Agave & Cacao, Vanilla & Anise, and Earl Grey & Cucumber. The dry down of Blue Agave & Cacao reminds me of DHI. I have yet to layer it with Vanilla & Anise, but I think it would make a very interesting final product. I can't say I find any of the offerings from Jo Malone complex, but they're good for what they are. I prefer some over others and their priced well enough to be affordable.
For sale thread ----> http://www.basenotes.net/threads/332...er-ToF-Samples
A woman at work wears one of the Cologne Intense fragrances (I think one of the Ouds but I'm not sure), and it projects like mad. I asked her if she was wearing Bulgari Omnia.
I found Sweet Lime & Cedar very challenging; it made me smell like a curry. Otherwise, like others, I find their fragrances pleasant but not very interesting.
I'm with the OP. I've tried them all, find a couple to be okay/nice, but really not worthy of purchase. But Pomegranate Noir does strike me as the most unique and interesting. It's not what I thought it would be at all from the note breakdown, and the cedar, rhubarb, and clove all interact in a fascinating way on my skin. It's got a lovely peppery, medicinal quality to it that really compliments the pomegranate itself. With that said, it's perhaps not quite as subtle as I'd ideally like it (it kind of reminds me of a Bond scent in that everything is loud and quite upfront), but I'd definitely say give it a spin as it does indeed have more character than some of the others.
Seems to be a nice fragrance, would there be samples available online ?
deadidol has my take on Pomegranate Noir, which is but for some small considerations a hell of a frgrance, not shy by any means and definitely interesting.
I find some of the very pleasant but so fleeting that they're not worth the money. I realise they're EDCs but some lasted only 10 minutes on me.
I have a FB of Intense Oud & Bergamot, and it is very nice layered with Cambodian Oud oil.
Well, it's cheaper than therapy... edit: No it's not...
I like Wild Fig & Cassis Cologne and Lime and Mandarin but as others have pointed out, they're overpriced and don't last long.
The only Joe Malone that I truly like (from those that I've smelled so far) is Lime Basil and Mandarin. All the others seem ho-hum.
I just love their oud Iriss. Incredible.
i thought their pure mint leaf was the cleanest take on spearmint i have tried.....if you ike cdg green or heelys menthe fraiche you will probably like jo malone pure mint leaf
14 sprays of DRAKKAR NOIR should do it
Jo Malone Frags are (Malone SA's self admittedly) simplistic, and they are now recommending that buyers intentionally add complexity and variability by buying several and combining them for a personalized approach.
But yes, for a simple, fun, not complex frag, Pom Noir and Vetyver Cafe have merits.
But the lack of complexity and minimalism was one of the hallmarks for commercial fragrances that I rebelled against when I started to formulate my line of niche fragrances. I guess my hallmarks are indeed complexity and longevity, purposely, because I rarely saw it in so many fragrances.
Gold Medal for "Best Aroma"; Los Angeles Artisan Fragrance Salon
A ha...a recent Jo Malone thread! Here's my story...
I got a number of Jo Malone vials at a Bloomingdales, specifically asking the lady which ones were more "masculine-smelling", or at least more preferred by men for themselves. She gave me:
Lime, Basil and Mandarin
Oud and Bergamot
Amber and Lavender
and I was impressed with how well they all fit the bill.
Looking through their nice little brochure, I was trying to find others to order from TPC or get vials from Neiman's or Nordstrom. Before I do, which of these would you say are the most masculine or feminine?
Amber and Patchouli
Blackberry and Bay
Earl Grey and Cucumber
Black Cedarwood and Juniper
Nutmeg and Ginger
Wild Fig and Cassis
Earl Grey and Cucumber-unisex leaning feminine.
Grapefruit-Unisex down the middle.
Nutmeg and Ginger-Unisex maybe slightly leaning masculine.
Saffron-Unisex but leaning masculine...to me.
Wild Fig and Cassis-Unisex down the middle.
I don't have any experience with Amber and Patchouli, or Black Cedarwood and Juniper. Of the one's you mention...my favorites are Wild Fig and Cassis, Saffron and Nutmeg and Ginger. Wild Fig is very realistic figs on a woody leafy fig tree. Saffron is creamy and good, and Nutmeg and Ginger is a little spicey...a little.
I love 154. Jo Malone fragrances are ones that you'd want to smell on another person. I'd hate to ride an elevator with most peoples definition of a 'complex' fragrance
Green Irish Tweed
The Noir 29
OK, thanks Kybid....that gives me a good starting point. A lot of the niche lines call their whole lineup unisex, which I think does the consumer a disservice since it's so common for them to lean one way or the other. Or to very clearly smell like men's or women's releases from designer lines (i.e. I'd be taken aback by Amber+Lavender or 154 on a woman!). Fortunately I have an eager recipient for any that are too feminine for me, I may just order all 8 anyway, and give the ones in question to her.
And Preston, yes, I'm starting to see this exact thing as their strong point, and wishing I had checked out the JM line sooner. They're interesting enough, without being too strange, but are quiet and not too pushy. The only problem is that some may just be too weak or too dull.